Tiffany Setting E-Ring, Help Choose Between The Two Stone

[nhi2112]

Hi! This is my very first post after stalking and learning so much from pricescope.
My bf and I both have our heart set on getting a Tiffany’s engagement ring specifically the Tiffany 6 prongs setting.
I am hesitating between these two diamonds and since I cannot see either in person, are there anything to help me determine the best one? Is it worth the extra $900 for the bigger one?

Diamond #1 — $22,500
Carat: 1.33
Depth: 62.3%
Table: 56%
Pavilion angle: 40.8
Crown angle: 35
Measurements: 7.01x7.02x4.37mm
HCA score: 1.5


Diamond #2 — $23,400
Carat: 1.38
Depth: 62%
Table: 56%
Pavilion angle: 40.9
Crown angle: 34.3
Measurements: 7.11x7.15x4.42mm
HCA score: 1.3

Both diamonds is Color G, Clarity VS2, Triple excellent with no fluorescence!

Thank you in advanced for all your help.

 

[Redwoods-hiker-girl]

Congratulations! Oh, your ring is going to be gorgeous. There's nothing quite like a Tiffany six-prong setting. In my opinion, you can't go wrong with either stone; the specs look good. I would lean ever so slightly more toward the 1.38, only because the 1.33 is a teensy bit deeper (though still within ideal specs).

 

[Avatar345]

The truth is both look good based on the specs; since those diamonds exist outside of the normal certification eco-system, there's not too much more to add. People will tell you you could get a lot more diamond for your money if you don't marry yourself to Tiffany's, but I say do what makes you feel good, and there is something special about Tiffany's after all

Everything being equal, I'd go with the larger diamond in this case

 

[lovedogs]

I personally wouldn't want to pay $900 more for a stone that is such a similar size.

 

[jp201845]

Visually you probably will not see a difference between the 2 diamonds with a very slight mm difference so I would save the money and put It towards the setting.

 

[Redwoods-hiker-girl]

Visually you probably will not see a difference between the 2 diamonds with a very slight mm difference so I would save the money and put It towards the setting.

The price includes the setting, at Tiffany.

 

[jp201845]

The price includes the setting, at Tiffany.

Then the savings can go towards something else or another bling project.

 

[Ally T]

The Tiffany 6 prong makes my heart sing!

I would also definitely go with the smaller stone, as visually you won't see the difference.

What an exciting time for you guys! Please come back & post when you get it!

 

[nhi2112]

Thank you everyone! My SA is bringing both into his store to take comparison pics for me. But it’s so hard to decides, I might just leave it to my bf to do the hard part!

I will surely keep you updated, thanks again.