Tianyu CAD Help- Pear Solitaire (Pic. Heavy)

[lovelylovelylife]

Hello everyone! 1st time starting a thread here!
I had a ring made by Tianyu that I had sent back because I wan't happy with the proportions they made the ring to. I didn't ask for all of the dimensions along the shank and this led to a ring that was taller than it was wide (looked like a flounder to me ). I ended up getting the shank height dimensions after I had already received it, and what was done was done. I also needed the ring re-sized by a good amount, so it just made sense to send it back to Tianyu. I am happy with the company so far because they did split the cost of the re-making with me. So their customer service has been helpful. I believe I'm just working with a newer employee who's not used to the proportions a ring is generally made to.

So it's finally time to have them create a new CAD with the dimensions I requested after they received back my ring.

I was wondering anyone could give me any input on this.
I will provide pictures of the original CAD, original ring, the inspo ring, and the newest CAD.
I'm not as interested in getting an EXACT replica of the inspo ring, but I do want a ring that is proportional and doesn't look... "odd." Thank you to anyone who can help!

In the new CAD, I had asked that the shoulders be more narrow, the height taper from 1.6mm to 1.8mm and 2.0mm. Here are my notes to Tianyu:

Original CAD's:
View media item 122654View media item 122653
Original Ring from TIANYU:
View media item 122650View media item 122652

Original ring from TIANYU (right) versus the INSPO ring (left):
View media item 122651
Inspo Ring:

NEW CAD 10/16/18:

 

[Taurus2313]

Well they certainly made the gaps smaller in the new CAD for you. Did you happen to have a side profile of the inspo ring to show them too?

 

[lovelylovelylife]

Well they certainly made the gaps smaller in the new CAD for you. Did you happen to have a side profile of the inspo ring to show them too?

There was somewhat of a side-profile to show them. But not a perfect dead-on side profile.
Here is the CAD I'm going to show them for edits to make for the next CAD.

 

[Taurus2313]

There was somewhat of a side-profile to show them. But not a perfect dead-on side profile.
Here is the CAD I'm going to show them for edits to make for the next CAD.

Looks like you did a great job explaining what you wanted your changes to be. I hope that they come through for you!

 

[Clemsonfan15]

I hate to bring up an old thread, but I was wondering how you liked the pear from Tianyu? Did the stone turn out well?

 

[lovelylovelylife]

I hate to bring up an old thread, but I was wondering how you liked the pear from Tianyu? Did the stone turn out well?

So I had the ring re-made & kept the same stone. I think the stone is perfect, I'm really have no expertise in buying stones though. I'll attach a bunch of pics It's a DEF color 8.5x5.5mm pear.
They suggested DEF, it's pretty white but does get more warm in different lighting. I probably could've gone warmer if I wanted it to be more diamond realistic (for what I could realistically afford for a diamond that size lol). I think it's beautiful personally. I do see a bow tie but it doesn't bother me. If you want different angles or light, let me know. https://www.dropbox.com/sh/uns47w92bmd4000/AAB4Qps1G2pB-WSoX8Q03uH6a?dl=0