So similar...

[porto]

damnit. the more i look the more i can''t decide.

All below are H&A ideal with AGS certs...

#1 .75ct F VS1 (cut advisor = 1.2, ex,ex,ex,vg) 3600
#2 .80ct G VS1 (cut advisor = 1.3, ex,ex,ex,vg) 3600
#3 .83ct G VS2 (cut advisor = 1.0, ex,ex,ex,vg) 3500

I already have the first one... should i return it and swap for #2 or #3?

 

[strmrdr]

What are the mm sizes and do you love the one you have?

 

[diamondseeker2006]

My exact question...we need to know the diameter to judge whether it would be worth swtiching to a larger appearing stone or not. If they were all the same size, then you may as well keep the one you have!

 

[porto]

#1 5.82 x 5.85 x 3.60
#3 5.98 x 6.01 x 3.69
#2 6.03 x 6.06 x 3.75

 

[porto]

ugh... it is in order above,

#1
#2
#3

 

[Ellen]

You are suffering buyers remorse, which can be normal. Stop it, you bought a great diamond. Now relax and enjoy it.

 

[belle]

why would you want to change? i''m sure the first one is lovely. you would be going through much hassle for little, if any, difference.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I have a .75 stone (2 actually, earrings) in my posession right now. It is only a tiiiiny bit bigger visually than a .70 stone that I have here. But psychologically, I would rather have the .75. In the case of your three stones, I''d rather have the .83 over a .75, especially if it is for a ring.

I know how it feels to have doubts, and in my case, I have shipped stones back more than once because I found something better. And I am glad I did.