Size difference between a 2 carat and 2.3 carat MRB

[MissGotRocks]

I'm going to guess F, G, H. However, this is based mostly on what you've told us about size and your thoughts on the stones.

There is no way I could or would make a decision based on that photo alone. The black background is very deceiving and while I realize that color is graded face down, did they send you any photos face up? It would be very nice to have a video ala GOG for comparison but not sure they do that. Has anyone at BGD given you their opinions on the stones? Could they do the same photo shoot on a white background?

 

[CareBear]

The G was originally AGS graded, but when I traded it in, it was re-graded by GIA, also a G.The H stone is GIA graded. The stones I own(ed) are all in the VS1-VS2 range, and they are all super eye-clean. So for me personally, a stone being VS1 or VS2 does affect my decision.

I mistyped earlier, I meant to say VS1 or VS2 does not affect my decision.

 

[JDDN]

I've just been told that the diamonds face up very bright white, which is probably true, but being color sensitive I wanted to try and see for myself. They did give me a photo of the diamonds face up and they are indistinguishable. I know....a GOG type video would be awesome. I also thought they would take the photos against a white background, but I should not have assumed!

I've decided to stick with a G (or an F if budget friendly). There is a stone I'm really interested in so we'll see what they have to say about it next week.

Oh, as far as the colors they are (going Left to Right): H, G, F

I thought the middle diamond looked the warmest and that's the G! But as you all have pointed out, it's really hard to tell in the photo.