shape
carat
color
clarity

Settings for Rhodolite Garnet- Suggestions please?

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

WishfulThinking

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Jan 10, 2007
Messages
1,437
Hey everyone,

I've only been a posting member of PS for a very short time, but I've lurked for a ridiculously long time before registering to join... warning: if I say things that a PSer [especially a years-long lurker] should know better than to suggest, feel free to intervene... Low-budget plea for help warning ahead!
20.gif


My girlfriend and I [we're both girls] are looking for suggestions for settings for a matched pair of Rhodolite Garnets that we purchased recently from AJSgems. They're gorgeous! I am trying to make two separate rings with these stones. They are meant to serve as a token of the love between my girlfriend and me -to symbolize a commitment to one another and to enjoy something that sparkles in the process! I suppose it's sort of a "promise ring" type thing, but we don't really refer to it that way. Since this is a very meaningful purchase, We'd like to get something that is beautiful and of a good quality, though we realize that on our budget it may not be what many here would consider to be the "best" quality. We're both undergraduate students, and the money is a little tight. Our expenses will only increase throughout graduate school, so we are hoping to make this purchase now and work the best we can with the money we have saved. Hopefully you can all help us navigate this process!

We are both girls, just to eliminate any confusion about settings or the project in general. We are not looking to purchase two identical settings, as each of us have our own distinct taste in jewelry, and probably could never agree on one thing.
20.gif
3.gif
At this point we would love to see what ideas PSers have for what sort of settings to put these lovely garnets into that fall within our price range. We think seeing what may be available to us will give us a better idea of the styles we like- really, anything is welcome!


THE STONES: 1.96 ctw
measure 5.70 x 5.70 x 4.10 mm each according to AJS.

Do you all think that since they were sold as a matched pair that the measurements given [which are supposed to apply to both stones] are accurate, or should I have them measured by a professional?

To be honest, we are really disappointed with the level of service [rather, lack thereof] that we've received at local jewelers... the fact that we live in an EXTREMELY rural area makes it even more tricky, as there are only a very two B&M jewelers and a Kays. Frankly, we'd prefer to not be "mauled"
32.gif
by Kays, but it's possible they may be one of the only pitifully limited options that we have to work with, especially in our price range. Bluntly: jewelers seem to be unwilling to work with us because either they are homophobic and unwilling to work with a same sex couple, or because we are not the most lucrative clients. They dismiss us as not having realistic expectations or not being worthwhile due to our smaller budget, or just not being human beings, I guess. I am not necessarily sure we are being unrealistic in our budget expectations, as we are very flexible. However, being treated rudely makes mus not want to pursue those options with the B&M jewelers we have available to us in person.

Thus, the internet!!!
36.gif
36.gif


OUR BUDGET: $500 total for both rings- so two settings.


Some ideas of what we are looking for:

Nothing insanely intricate or busy- obviously we are realistic about what we expect with this project.

-Settings with sidestones/accents- nothing too fancy, since our budget will likely not allow it.
-Affordable but pretty: the possibility [hope?] that very small accent diamonds may be able to pass with lower quality than we would choose for a project with a higher budget and larger stone.-Nothing with entirely plain bands, but engraving is an option we may consider

Those are the ideas we have so far, and we are open to suggestions.

Sorry to write a novel- we look forward to seeing what you all come up with for suggestions, and we will be so happy and grateful to have your input, so we hope people respond!!

ETA: I hope it's okay to post in this forum regarding a setting for a colored stone- I mentioned this topic in the colored stone forum and someone suggested we might find more people to help us here. Sorry if that's in violation of any rule- we thought since it's about settings it would be okay. :)
 
Some suggestions we've looked at:

Someone in the colored forum pointed me to Stuller. I hear they have decently priced stuff, but I can't see the prices on their website since I am not a retailer, or whatever it is you have to be. I was advised to work with a B&M locally to get a setting from Stuller, but as I said above, I don't think that's an option. The people I talked to were not at all receptive to the idea of a setting that didn't cost a ton, and refused to even give me a ballpark figure.

here is a Stuller setting that we like:


pretty with sidestones!
Is there any way an online vendor could get me a price quote for a Stuller setting? Are they willing to work with clients like me in these services?

I personally also adore this setting...
Please don't take away my PS card forever for this...
Okay... know, I know. Not really a reputable store? Has anyone ever heard of them? We don't expect the quality to be mindblowing or anything- just look NICE and pretty and not cheap and horrible. What do you all think of this idea? Am I crazy? Are the stones not quality enough to sparkle, do you think? We are not expecting Whiteflash ACA melee or anything... They apparently have a 30 day return policy, which is good, but we'd have to be VERY careful with how we package it/go about the return, because it seems like they're trying to catch customers in a mistake and not allow the return... or that's the vibe we got from it. Which is obviously not ideal.

ETA:
Again...

Any thoughts? Any suggestions? We'd so appreciate any input you could give.Craziness?
Are we going about this all wrong? What's the opinion on cubic z for something like this- will it look pretty? It's definitely a less expensive option, and could be considered if it would look nice.
33.gif
 
I''m sorry you had a bad experience with your local jewelers. The online jewelers that are members here can''t give you a quote here in this thread because it would be considered solicitation of business, but they all have accounts with Stuller and could give you a quote if you contacted them directly.
 
Date: 1/9/2008 9:13:27 PM
Author: urseberry
I''m sorry you had a bad experience with your local jewelers. The online jewelers that are members here can''t give you a quote here in this thread because it would be considered solicitation of business, but they all have accounts with Stuller and could give you a quote if you contacted them directly.
Thanks for responding! I think we will do that, but we''re hoping to get a more solid idea of what we''d like, and perhaps expand our search outside of Stuller, since the setting I linked to is the only one we really like on the site. I also have another question- how would it work to purchase a setting from Stuller through Whiteflash? It might sound like a stupid question, but who gets the pay? Would Whiteflash set the stone for a fee? Is it easy? Has anyone ever done it? Full of questions...
20.gif


We''re also hoping that all of you here might give some input on styles and other possibilities that might be available as well. I really hope more people respond- I always feel bad when no one does!
 
Wishfulthinking,

I know that whiteflash has some simple solitairs that are within your budget, and I think they will set your stones (though I am not totally sure, you''d have to call them):

http://www.whiteflash.com/Engagement-Rings/Styles/Solitaire/1.htm

Your best bet is probably to spent some time trolling the designer links on pricescope''s main page.

Good luck, can''t wait to see how it turns out!

DD
35.gif


PS: To get more responses, maybe try posting a simple question on "Show me the ring" with the subject line "Show me your inexpesive settings!" and then say you are looking for settings under $250 and see what you get!
 
Wishful thinking - my suggestion is to contact either/both Wink Jones, who can source from both stuller and other setting catalogs, and also Michael Edgett at Gemshoppe. I have worked with both and they can be trusted to set your stones well for a good value. Unfortunately in this day and age there is no such thing as both good quality and inexpensive for jewelry settings because of the rise in metal prices. However they would be able to tell you what is feasible in your price range.
Good luck!
 
For this budget, I would definitely suggest you take a look through adwar casting co catelogs. They offer pre-casted settings that a jeweler will finish up and put diamonds into. I think WF will work with adwar with you and a couple of people here on ps have done this. I think that WF would be completely fine working with a same sex couple as well.
 
Thank you dreamer_dachsie, part gypsy, and kcoursolle!

All of your responses have been very helpful. We will be considering all of our options over about the next half a year, and will definitely be back to PS to let everyone know how it turns out- with lots of pictures!
36.gif


Thanks again.
1.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top