How did you decide which you wanted to do? I have a 1.07 cushion and my ring size is now 5 1/2 (used to be 4 1/2 pre pregnancy.) I am really wanting more finger coverage and sparkle. I have always loved the look of a halo and was considering having David Klass reset my stone (which is now a solitaire with a pave band and w-ring) into a custom halo setting. But now my husband is wondering if we should just upgrade the stone (bought from ERD about 7 years ago) for a bigger cushion but then put it in a very simple solitaire. He likes that look better, but I like more detailed settings and am somewhat attached to my original stone. Do worry I'd get sick of a halo though and I'd really like this to be the forever setting for my ering. Any words of wisdom?