Received two LightBox 2ct loose diamonds

[diamondgeeknerd]

Hi everyone. I purchased two Lightbox 2 ct diamond from early this month hoping at least of them is good.. I was trying to confirm the light performance but I don’t have any ASET/ IS tool yet so I followed DIY ASET step by step. I think I let too much direct light in so it didn’t turn out the way it should. But I was able to capture some arrows using this method. If I am to keep one I think I will pick the first one.. Let me know what you think about the stones and/or I should keep them!

First one:



Second one:

 

[lovedogs]

The first one looks pretty nice! The second one is much less good

 

[diamondgeeknerd]

The first one looks pretty nice! The second one is much less good

Thank you for your input. I am seriously thinking to buy an ASET tool to confirm first stone is good since I am not experienced enough to tell light performance with naked eye but I am probably not experienced enough to use the tool either lol

 

[FL_runner]

When considering the arrows and symmetry the first looks pretty good!

Do you have any other pictures? When you look at them side by side what do you think based on what your eye sees?

 

[DejaWiz]

First one appears to have a high degree of light return.
Second one does not...the windowing/leakage is quite apparent in the picture.

 

[diamondgeeknerd]

View attachment 875558

Here are more pictures and videos. What do you think about the light return of the better one (the one on top) ? Thank you.

 

[Dee Dee]

Looks pretty nice to me. Did you decide to keep or return? How do they show up on real life?