Please review and comment with these 3 diamonds

[jayrun79]

Please review which diamond you think is the best. I requested IS image, so I will post them soon as I get it. Thanks

Diamond 1

1.64 carat
Color H
Clarity SI1
7.55 x 7.57 x 4.70
Dept 62.2%
Table 57%
Crown 34.5%
Pavilion 41.4%
Girdle med-slightly thick
Cut/pol/sym all excellent except sym very good
HCA score: 4.8



Diamond 2

1.64 carat
Color I
Clarity VS1
7.56 x 7.59 x 4.64
Dept 61.3%
Table 58%
Crown 35%
Pavilion 41%
Girdle med
Cut/pol/sym all excellent
HCA score: 2.4



Diamond 3

1.66 carat
Color I
Clarity VS2
7.57 x 7.63 x 4.72
Dept 62.1%
Table 55%
Crown 35%
Pavilion 40.8%
Girdle thin-slightly thick
Cut/pol/sym all excellent
HCA score: 1.6

Your feedback and comments would greatly be appreciate it. Thanks

 

[diamondseeker2006]

#3 is best. #1 should be eliminated.

 

[minmin001]

3