Please help to choose between diamonds

[Magdalena_rocks]

Hello guys,
First, thank you for amazing opportunity to learn from experts on this forum.
Would anybody be so kind to help me choose between this diamonds?

1) Depth 61.6%, Table 56.7%, CA 34.8°, Crown height 15.1%, PA 40.6°, Pavilion depth 42.8%, Girdle thin to medium 1.8%-3.8%, Star length 51%, Lower half 77%



2) Depth 61.6%, Table 56.7%, CA 34.7°, Crown height 15.0%, PA 40.7°, Pavilion depth 43.0%, Girdle thin to slightly thick 1.6%-4.1%, Star length 53%, Lower half 76%

 

[solgen]

Looks like both will perform well so go with whichever appeals to you. I'd opt for #1 personally.

 

[Magdalena_rocks]

Thank you very much Solgen. Unfortunately, I can't see them in person. Anybody else? Please share your thoughts, these ones are so similar, it's really difficult to choose...

 

[ecf8503]

The images are great on them both. Is one higher color? Is one bigger (mm dimensions) than the other?

 

[Magdalena_rocks]

same color, same clarity, basically same size too

 

[newjourney]

Hi,

I've just been in your shoes and can relate. Those are great choices. Based on those images, my vote is for the first one since the clarity seems better.
If possible, please request for a diffuse light video clip of both. It will provide 3D perspective and hopefully, you will gravitate toward one more than the other. Best of luck!

 

[Magdalena_rocks]

newjourney- thank you very much for advice!

 

[tyty333]

I vote for the first one (they both look nice though).

Can the gemlogist at wherever they are located compare them and tell you what they see?

 

[Magdalena_rocks]

Thank you very much Tyty333 So far 3:0 for the stone no.1!

 

[craiguk]

They look like WF pictures. If so are they both ACA? They look it. Agreed that the first one does look better but only because the second one looks slightly warmer. Obviously can't be the case though if the same colour. A video would be a great idea and if they're from who I think they'll be happy to do it for you.