Please help me decide on which type of everyday necklace

[zah_zah]

Yes totally eye clean. I asked them to check twice and asked them a tonne of questions. so I have decided im going to order tonight. I just need to call up to ask them one thing about the setting (which i decided on platinum) which I hope is more hard wearing than white gold.

 

[zah_zah]

Zah, there are two of ame's choices that I really like. They are both a little bigger yet cheaper than the stone you're looking at, and both have great HCA scores. They're Si1 not VS2. I think you're a little unsure of Si1? Blue Nile can tell you if they're eyeclean, and I think you'd have more to worry about with an Si2. From what I've read here, Si1s from a reputable place like BN are often eyeclean. And like you said, you can always return - and lower the chances of disappointment by asking BN if they're eyeclean, too. Just seems a pity to miss out on a bigger, cheaper diamond because of clarity concerns. Many people on this website have eyeclean Si1s. However, if you're more comfortable with VS2 then I think the one you linked will also be lovely.

This one that ame chose is an excellent price, almost 70 pounds cheaper than the VS2, and a little bigger:
http://www.bluenile.com/uk/diamond-details/LD05030294

This one that ame chose is 130 pounds cheaper than the VS2, and still a couple of points bigger:
http://www.bluenile.com/uk/diamond-details/LD05115542

If you prefer a VS2 for mindclean reasons, that's one thing and you should get the 0.56 VS2 if you genuinely prefer higher clarity for its own sake.

But if you'd be happy with an eyeclean Si1 and are drawing toward the VS2 mainly out of purchase nervousness, it would be a pity to miss out on diamonds that are slightly larger and many pounds cheaper.

I went to buy my pendant last night and the 0.61 was already sold, even though it went through I got told it was sold

So I have reserved the 0.58 and I think im going for that. they have also apologized as when i went through with the processing of buying it was still available. anyways they have suggested some alternatives but Im not sure if they are any good.

Just edited my post, as I checked them all through the HCA and they dont score amazingly.

 

[zah_zah]

I was also told with this diamond there are a few crystals but they are colorless one is in the table and a couple near the edge? is this a cause of worry?

 

[Jambalaya]

Hi zah,

I'm so sorry the other diamond sold. I guess it's that time of year - people shopping for Christmas etc.

I think that a GIA-certified Si1 should be just fine. I don't know that much about clarity, but GIA is a very reputable lab. Also, as you said, pendants don't get the wear and tear that rings do. I have a diamond with a small black crystal under the table and one near the edge. The ring has held up through a lot of wear. It's an Si1 graded by the other reputable lab, AGS.

I'm glad you have reserved the 0.58. I'll just have a quick squizz through the inventory to make sure that it's the best choice, if you like? I'm just wondering if more have been added in the last few days.

 

[Jambalaya]

Zah, this one is nice and big at 0.64, H Si1, HCA 1.5, and is only about 25 pounds more than you were going to pay for one of the other diamonds. It's 1,423 pounds, and the white X is right on the AGS box line, and a 55% table.

http://www.bluenile.com/uk/diamond-details/LD05030469


(I've read that some people who know about diamonds like a small/55% table, and I think it's because it means there's more crown space to shoot sparkle from. Here's a thread about it: [URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/which-rb-would-you-choose-55-and-59-table.184714/..']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/which-rb-would-you-choose-55-and-59-table.184714/....[/URL]. ****Edited post to add info about table****)


I think what differentiates this diamond is the size. (All the diamonds in this thread have great-looking cuts)

 

[Jambalaya]

OK, I looked at 60/60 diamonds also, but I don't think there's anything that beats the 0.58 for under 1300 pounds that you have on hold, or the possible 0.64 linked above.

The choice is yours!!

 

[Jambalaya]

P.S. Just wanted to say that the 0.58 will be lovely too, and a great price at 1260 pounds.

 

[Jambalaya]

Just realized that the diamond I linked above, I also linked earlier in this thread. Sorry to double-link!

 

[Jambalaya]

Zah, this one is nice and big at 0.64, H Si1, HCA 1.5, and is only about 25 pounds more than you were going to pay for one of the other diamonds. It's 1,423 pounds, and the white X is right on the AGS box line.

http://www.bluenile.com/uk/diamond-details/LD05030469

I think what differentiates this diamond is the size. (All the diamonds in this thread have great-looking cuts)

Zah, I predict your next question is going to be about twinning wisps, since that is the inclusion listed on the cert for this diamond!

So here are some links: [URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/twinning-wisp.26447/']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/twinning-wisp.26447/[/URL]

[URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/twinning-wisp-how-exactly-does-it-affect-brilliance.199865/']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/twinning-wisp-how-exactly-does-it-affect-brilliance.199865/[/URL]

[URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/twinning-wisp-lower-class-diamond.155635/']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/twinning-wisp-lower-class-diamond.155635/[/URL] In this link, knowledgeable posters are saying that twinning wisps are hard to spot even with a loupe.

From casting my eye over those threads, it seems that twinning wisps graded Si1 from a reputable lab are OK, and if the're graded Si2 you'd have more reason to worry.

I think it really comes down to how much you want to spend, and if spending another 163 pounds to get a diamond that's six points bigger is worth it to you. Be aware that people on Pricescope talk about DSS (diamond shrinkage syndrome). For myself, I try to get the best I can stretch to at the time because I figure that another 150 or so isn't going to mean much over the rest of my lifetime but I'll always have the bigger diamond. But that's just my psychology. Many people are more frugal than I am. I think that 0.58 for 1260 pounds will also be a beautiful and cost-effective choice.

 

[zah_zah]

Zah, this one is nice and big at 0.64, H Si1, HCA 1.5, and is only about 25 pounds more than you were going to pay for one of the other diamonds. It's 1,423 pounds, and the white X is right on the AGS box line.

http://www.bluenile.com/uk/diamond-details/LD05030469

I think what differentiates this diamond is the size. (All the diamonds in this thread have great-looking cuts)

Zah, I predict your next question is going to be about twinning wisps, since that is the inclusion listed on the cert for this diamond!

So here are some links: [URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/twinning-wisp.26447/']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/twinning-wisp.26447/[/URL]

[URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/twinning-wisp-how-exactly-does-it-affect-brilliance.199865/']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/twinning-wisp-how-exactly-does-it-affect-brilliance.199865/[/URL]

[URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/twinning-wisp-lower-class-diamond.155635/']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/twinning-wisp-lower-class-diamond.155635/[/URL] In this link, knowledgeable posters are saying that twinning wisps are hard to spot even with a loupe.

From casting my eye over those threads, it seems that twinning wisps graded Si1 from a reputable lab are OK, and if the're graded Si2 you'd have more reason to worry.

I think it really comes down to how much you want to spend, and if spending another 163 pounds to get a diamond that's six points bigger is worth it to you. Be aware that people on Pricescope talk about DSS (diamond shrinkage syndrome). For myself, I try to get the best I can stretch to at the time because I figure that another 150 or so isn't going to mean much over the rest of my lifetime but I'll always have the bigger diamond. But that's just my psychology. Many people are more frugal than I am. I think that 0.58 for 1260 pounds will also be a beautiful and cost-effective choice.

Thank you so much for your help I'm leaning towards a bigger diamond my only concern is he twinning wisp some say it's bad and effect brilliance whilst some say ts great as it's hard to see.

I called up bluenile they have also reserved this for me and said it's eye clean.
I now have 24 hours to decide!
Eeek

 

[Jambalaya]

Glad you have both diamonds on reserve! Now neither will get away.

Since the 0.64 is graded Si1 not Si2 by GIA, and it's eyeclean, I really would have thought it'd be fine. However, if you can't find satisfactory answers by researching old threads and you're still not sure, why not start a thread asking for the experts' opinions on twinning wisps? Specifically, a wisp graded Si1 by GIA in an eyeclean stone. See what they say. I wish I could help you further but I don't know all that much about clarity.

Am so excited for you about this purchase! Will you post some photos when you get it? I'm quite interested to see that Blue Nile setting in real life.

 

[zah_zah]

Hi!

Just an update. I have chosen the diamond and have placed my order!
Its a suprise! will post pictures when i get my pendant! Hope its sparkly as I hope!

 

[CRYSTAL24K]

Can't wait to see pics!

 

[MichelleCarmen]

Congrats! Hope you love it.

 

[Jambalaya]

Oh, yay!!!! I was wondering what had happened.

So it's a surprise? You are teasing us!!!

 

[marymm]

So glad you found your diamond - I really look forward to seeing your finished pendant!

 

[zah_zah]

Sorry for the disappearance I was struggling to decide on a diamond and called up bluenile quite a few times to discuss and we decided on a diamond and the petite bail setting and hopefully should get my pendant before the 18th do excited to wear it especially ok Xmas day

 

[Kalliope]

Hey zahzah,

I assume you didn't go with the 0.64 H SI1 since it's available again at BN. May I ask why (I have been thinking of buying it myself)?

 

[ame]

I think I can answer for her since I was talking to her about this--the reason she didn't select that stone was that she ultimately preferred the mind-cleanliness of a VS stone plus the greater likelihood of the stone being eyeclean to her standards. The size difference is not great enough to warrant the carat increase. Correct me if I am wrong, ZahZah.

 

[Kalliope]

I think I can answer for her since I was talking to her about this--the reason she didn't select that stone was that she ultimately preferred the mind-cleanliness of a VS stone plus the greater likelihood of the stone being eyeclean to her standards. The size difference is not great enough to warrant the carat increase. Correct me if I am wrong, ZahZah.

Thanks ame! I thought maybe zah-zah got a picture of and/or other information on the stone and would share it with me .

 

[zah_zah]

Hey my pendant is going to arrive soon!
I'm a excited and nervous I hope it's not too small especially in the petite bail.

 

[zah_zah]

I think I can answer for her since I was talking to her about this--the reason she didn't select that stone was that she ultimately preferred the mind-cleanliness of a VS stone plus the greater likelihood of the stone being eyeclean to her standards. The size difference is not great enough to warrant the carat increase. Correct me if I am wrong, ZahZah.

Thanks ame for answering you are correct.

If prefer a vs over si especially since I am buying over the internet.
Also as I'm not 100% sure about twinning wisps I was afraid of it.

 

[zah_zah]

Hey zahzah,

I assume you didn't go with the 0.64 H SI1 since it's available again at BN. May I ask why (I have been thinking of buying it myself)?

Hey sorry I didn't get back to you sooner.

As ame said I prefer something to be mind clean especially since I was buying it without seeing the diamond itself.

Having never brought anything lower than VS quality I guess I was just afraid. I know for a pendant I won't be inspecting it as much as saying a ring but at the same time once you see an inclusion you will always find it again and know it's there.

I didn't ask for any pictures sorry! Although I was told by bluenile staff it was eye clean (6-8 inches away is what they define eye clean) and had no pressure sensitive inclusions.
But if it's still available do call up and ask they can send magnified pictures of some stone not all unfortunatly but some of they they can.

 

[Kalliope]

Hey zah_zah!

I eventually asked for a picture of the 0.64 and posted it in my thread, too. Although the stone is eyeclean the inclusion was too visible for me so I passed on this one.

May I ask you about the purchasing process at BN? I saw that they add the VAT to the total price, so you don't have to pay anything when the package arrives?

Can't wait to see some pics of your necklace !

 

[zah_zah]

Hey zah_zah!

I eventually asked for a picture of the 0.64 and posted it in my thread, too. Although the stone is eyeclean the inclusion was too visible for me so I passed on this one.

May I ask you about the purchasing process at BN? I saw that they add the VAT to the total price, so you don't have to pay anything when the package arrives?

Can't wait to see some pics of your necklace !

Hey that's a shame that you could see inclusions but keep an eye out and defiantly post ones you like there's so many helpful people on the site

The process is pretty simple really I'm from the UK so VAT is included with the final price so not added cost which is great. Shipping is free.
Ok excited and nervous about seeing my pendant it arrives tomorrow wooh!

 

[zah_zah]

Also bluenile are very helpful and they also have an upgrade option for the future!

 

[zah_zah]

My pendant has arrived although I'm at work so will have to go collect it! I'm so excited but already thinking if it's to small eeek

 

[ame]

My pendant has arrived although I'm at work so will have to go collect it! I'm so excited but already thinking if it's to small eeek

I bet it's perfect. I can't wait to see!!!

 

[zah_zah]

I just recived my necklace and unwrapped it and I LOVE it!

It's so sparkly! And defiantly not too small.will take pictures!

ThAnks so much to everyone who helped me decide

 

[Kalliope]

Yay, so happy for you ! Can't wait to see pics!