First poster here so please bare with me 
. So I recently purchased a Diamond from a local diamond shop that was recommended to me. I utilized a lot of the awesome information here to find the best possible diamond and I eventually wound up with what was a really beautiful stone on paper and in person (it meets all the ideal oval cut requirements I found on this site for an oval). I took a gamble though as the stone was EGL knowing that they can exaggerate well everything. The diamond on paper seemed perfect (right around 2ct, H, SI1, Table and Depth were perfect). I saw it in person and it looked pretty amazing (at least in the jewelry store) was the right size (perfect size, sparkling, with no noticeable inclusions. I had it placed in a custom rose gold bezel set setting (similar to James Allen) picked it up and in the store it looked fantastic. Now I've brought it home now I'm getting second thoughts. In regular sunlight it's not really noticeable and looks pretty great I think but in warmer light just north and south of the center it gets a yellowish tint. I'm not quite sure if it's picking up the color from the lights,the rose gold setting, or both and I'm not quite sure if that is what is normal. I asked a few lady friends they thought it looked great but I was getting paranoid so I took it to another diamond shop and they said it's definitely closer to J maybe even K if it was GIA certified (which really got me worrying). The jeweler said that was fine though as the warmer stone kind of compliments the setting and that it was in fact a really beautiful stone/ring. Should I bring it back (and exchange for perhaps a smaller more colorless diamond (I doubt I can return at this point but I'm almost positive I can exchange) or just proceed as is (does this occur in most diamonds and perhaps I'm just being too picky). I've attached photos for comparison sake and I'm really looking for some advice on what steps to take next. Thanks in advance!
. So I recently purchased a Diamond from a local diamond shop that was recommended to me. I utilized a lot of the awesome information here to find the best possible diamond and I eventually wound up with what was a really beautiful stone on paper and in person (it meets all the ideal oval cut requirements I found on this site for an oval). I took a gamble though as the stone was EGL knowing that they can exaggerate well everything. The diamond on paper seemed perfect (right around 2ct, H, SI1, Table and Depth were perfect). I saw it in person and it looked pretty amazing (at least in the jewelry store) was the right size (perfect size, sparkling, with no noticeable inclusions. I had it placed in a custom rose gold bezel set setting (similar to James Allen) picked it up and in the store it looked fantastic. Now I've brought it home now I'm getting second thoughts. In regular sunlight it's not really noticeable and looks pretty great I think but in warmer light just north and south of the center it gets a yellowish tint. I'm not quite sure if it's picking up the color from the lights,the rose gold setting, or both and I'm not quite sure if that is what is normal. I asked a few lady friends they thought it looked great but I was getting paranoid so I took it to another diamond shop and they said it's definitely closer to J maybe even K if it was GIA certified (which really got me worrying). The jeweler said that was fine though as the warmer stone kind of compliments the setting and that it was in fact a really beautiful stone/ring. Should I bring it back (and exchange for perhaps a smaller more colorless diamond (I doubt I can return at this point but I'm almost positive I can exchange) or just proceed as is (does this occur in most diamonds and perhaps I'm just being too picky). I've attached photos for comparison sake and I'm really looking for some advice on what steps to take next. Thanks in advance!
300x240.png)