pepsi_corp
Rough_Rock
- Joined
- Feb 22, 2009
- Messages
- 23
Hi all,
I have read all the countless debates about not necessarily getting better quality in a ''branded'' name such as Cartier or Tiffany, and do not wish to rehash those arguments.
Plain and simple, from the perspective of a girl on a receiving end (or for other guys who want to chime in), which would you rather ''receive''?? The questions for guys would be- would you fork out the extra couple G''s??
Here are some hypothetical specs:
Tiffany Classic setting (six prong)
1.3 carat G VS2 (exc/exc/exc- GIA) - $15000
HCA < 2.0
Vs
Carter 1895 solitaire (NOT the pave)
1.3 carat G VS2 (exc/exc/exc- GIA) - $15000
HCA < 2.0
Vs
Self-selection (online vendors) any setting (solitaire OR multistone)
1.36 carat F VS2 (ideal/ideal/idea- AGS0) - $13000
HCA < 2.0
Personal opinions greatly appreciated. Don''t be too obvious with the ''depends on the girl'' and ''depends whether you think the extra 2K is worth it'' responses.
Much appreciated all...have fun!
I have read all the countless debates about not necessarily getting better quality in a ''branded'' name such as Cartier or Tiffany, and do not wish to rehash those arguments.
Plain and simple, from the perspective of a girl on a receiving end (or for other guys who want to chime in), which would you rather ''receive''?? The questions for guys would be- would you fork out the extra couple G''s??
Here are some hypothetical specs:
Tiffany Classic setting (six prong)
1.3 carat G VS2 (exc/exc/exc- GIA) - $15000
HCA < 2.0
Vs
Carter 1895 solitaire (NOT the pave)
1.3 carat G VS2 (exc/exc/exc- GIA) - $15000
HCA < 2.0
Vs
Self-selection (online vendors) any setting (solitaire OR multistone)
1.36 carat F VS2 (ideal/ideal/idea- AGS0) - $13000
HCA < 2.0
Personal opinions greatly appreciated. Don''t be too obvious with the ''depends on the girl'' and ''depends whether you think the extra 2K is worth it'' responses.
Much appreciated all...have fun!
