Hi guys, first time ring buyer here and picking out EC stone...GF cares nothing about quality and is all about the size. But i don't think she wants to be looking at a big ole black carbon in the middle. She wears a size 8, and I'm on a budget. Found this 1.60CT from a reputable seller and he swears it will be eye clean and white. It is IGI certified SI1 K color. Here is the picture they sent me and the setting its going in. And then I found a 1.23 F color SI 1 with EGL grading this looks super clean. Whats your guys thoughts?
1.60CT
8.17 x 5.82

1.23CT
7.77 x 5.06

The setting

1.60CT
8.17 x 5.82

1.23CT
7.77 x 5.06

The setting
