need help deciding

[icey]

I know everyone here will tell me it''s not worth it,but if you had to decide which would you pick:

Tiffany 1.76 ct F VS1
7.68x7.77x4.81
Depth 62.3
Table 57
Girdle med to slightly thick
culet small
very good/very good

Cartier 1.68 ct F VVS2
7.71x7.8x4.66
D 60.1
T 50 or 60(i think it says 50)
Girdle thin to med faceted
culet none
very good/ good
flouresence none
They are both comparably priced(mid 20''s)/ round ,just differnt settings

Thanks

 

[Lanee]

You're right about what I'll say, I would picked not to buy and e-ring from either store.

 

[Hest88]

Neither. I'd ask Cartier to get me a better cut diamond and then pick the new Cartier.

 

[mike04456]

I think Leonid needs to put some kind of warning along the top of the forum page about exercising caution when starting Tiffany threads.

Personally, I have a niece named Tiffany, and I think she's worth every cent!