Need help choosing between 2 round stones

[amylieu14]

Hi Everyone,

Wanted to get an honest opinion. My jeweler has been sending me alternative stones since the only one I saw i didn't like. I'm going to see her this Sat and wanted some opinions.

Price range of these two are supposedly around 12k.

This one I'm weary of since the comment mentions that there are clouds not shown

GIA REPORT: 2151375304
Measurements
7.11 - 7.16 x 4.47 mm
Carat Weight 1.40 carat
Color Grade G
Clarity Grade VS1
Cut Grade Excellent

I feel as though even though this one might be the winner?

GIA REPORT: 2161640484

Measurements 7.24 - 7.27 x 4.46 mm
Carat Weight 1.41 carat
Color Grade F
Clarity Grade VS2
Cut Grade Excellent

i appreciate all feedbacks. this will be going into a halo cushion setting.

Thank you!

 

[solgen]

First one is a bit deep and high crown angle too.

Second one isn't any better.

I'd look at other diamonds as neither are that great.