Need advice on diamond

[tb8z]

Hello all,

First time poster, and really appreciate the advice on this forum thus far!
I had a question about a diamond I've been looking at online, the specs are:

Diamond 1
2.50 J VS2 eyeclean
GIA Triple Ex
61.2 depth
58 table
35.5 crown angle
40.6 pavilion angle
strong blue fluorescence
medium/slightly thick girdle
cloud on table
HCA 1.4
$16.5k

I can't get pictures of Diamond 1, but can you guys compare this to a previous diamond listed on this site?

Diamond 2
https://enchanteddiamonds.com/diamonds/view/R250-RHSEK1
2.50 J SI1 (looks eyeclean?)
GIA Triple Ex
62.3 depth
58 table
35.5 crown angle
40.8 pavilion angle
no fluorescence
medium/slightly thick girdle
SI1 from large cloud not pictured
HCA 2.8

This is I believe listed for $15.5k, with a video and ASET (is the ASET representative of a 2.4? I haven't seen enough to read them )

Mainly wondering if Diamond 1's 2.50 J VS2's strong fluorescence could potentially help the J color and make it a good buy, or if in comparison Diamond 2 (which has pictures/video/ASET) is a better deal, or maybe both are poor. Thanks in advance!

 

[tb8z]

Diamond 1 GIA

 

[tyty333]

The second diamond looks ever so slightly leaky under the table. IMO probably not enough to effect the beauty of the stone
(so unless you are looking for perfection...).

 

[tb8z]

Thanks tyty333!

A point I'm a bit confused about with Diamond 2; does the ASET image reflect a diamond with a poor HCA 2.8, or does the HCA not matter in this case? Also for Diamond 2, should I be worried about haziness due to the SI1 grading (Clarity grade based on clouds that are not shown)? I can't tell from the video what is cloudy and what is not... thanks again for advice!