Hello all! I’m a new member but always browsed the site. I wanted to post a few pictures of my engagement ring (got engaged Friday so i just got it ). It is a 4.53 carat K color VS2 old mine cut. I told my fiancé that I wanted an antique diamond; however, I did not do my research and did not understand that many of the larger stones are in the lower color grades. I always loved the chunkier facets and the look of them- I also love that they are a bit more rugged and imperfect but for some reason the fact that mine is a K and looks a bit warmer in some lighting is making me feel a little insecure about it. Otherwise I love it so much so I suppose I shouldn’t care? I also didn’t expect a diamond that is as big as this! He compared this one to a 2 carat antique “style” g color and I’m wondering if that would have been a better choice. I feel like I really would have wanted one that is authentically old. Anyway, here are some pics I would love to know your thoughts: