Thanks PS for all of the helpful advice. I feel like a diamond expert compared to what I knew when I started looking two and a half weeks ago. I found the stone that was exactly what I was looking for, a beautiful GIA XXX 1.53 I/SI1 that's completely eye clean and looks amazing!
Now it's off to the jeweler to pick a setting, and then figure out how to pop the question!
Thanks again for all of the advice & opinions over the last few weeks. The information I found on this site / forum gave me the confidence I needed to make such a big decision!
Here it is in a temporary setting from JA:

Now it's off to the jeweler to pick a setting, and then figure out how to pop the question!
Thanks again for all of the advice & opinions over the last few weeks. The information I found on this site / forum gave me the confidence I needed to make such a big decision!
Here it is in a temporary setting from JA:
