the color, even with the zoning of number one is nice, the window is insurmountable. Number 2 has all the charm of one of those kernels of popcorn at the bottom of the cup that didnt pop, or popped a tiny bit and then stopped.
eta: as rare as the stuff is, there are nice examples to be had. I would hold out for that
Firstly, what is your intention in getting one? Is it just because of the rarity factor or are you looking for something that is a good specimen for that variety? If it is the latter, I’d hold out for something better. #1 is going to be dead with that bay door killing whatever colour and life the stone has. #2 is a cut better but still not an attractive stone.