Is this ring Edwardian?

[twosanguinehearts]

Hi! I’m considering an original antique diamond ring and wondering what era it might be from? Seller isn’t 100% sure. Edwardian is my best guess but would love to get your thoughts. I typically prefer Victorian jewelry but this one caught my eye. Thank you!

 

[LilAlex]

What's the metal? I think of lighter, more delicate, and more open work on the face-up side -- and in platinum. The gallery is pretty but what does the top look like (and, I guess, what is the name that grown-ups use for the "top")?

 

[Rfisher]

I love love the setting!

 

[YadaYadaYada]

Sexy shoulders, you know on the ring

I am not sure about time period but it is gorgeous whenever it originates from.

 

[nala]

We definitely need more angles to tell. And close-up’s. Immediately!

 

[Mreader]

We definitely need more angles to tell. And close-up’s. Immediately!

100% this!

 

[stracci2000]

It's beautiful.
A straight -on view, please?

 

[LightBright]

I’m stumped. It’s got some design elements (fishtail pattern around the circumference and organic/naturalistic design element where shoulders meet the top of the ring) that are not typical of American Edwardian design, in my inexperienced opinion.

OTOH really fine Miligrain and fine detailed craftsmanship is typical of that time. Edwardian lavished such craftsmanship/so many diamonds on settings. Diamonds are cut like my own Edwardian era halo diamonds (cut looks more modern, lower crown). Platinum looks like iridium PT, patinaed like an old piece.

My guess is real Edwardian. I think it’s a really fabulous setting! Please take it home!

 

[RRfromR]

Beautiful! Do I see a rose cut on top?

 

[LightBright]

Beautiful! Do I see a rose cut on top?

The diamond in the center looks like a high crowned OEC to me.

 

[lulu_ma]

I'm not an expert, but based on my few Edwardian pieces, it looks more like a revival/ inspired by piece to me. I have the same thought about my newest ring too!

 

[Rfisher]

I'm not an expert, but based on my few Edwardian pieces, it looks more like a revival/ inspired by piece to me. I have the same thought about my newest ring too!

I agree with this.
And really really nicely done. That’s some mad skilled work of someone.

 

[twosanguinehearts]

How could I forget the head-on shot!!!

 

[twosanguinehearts]

The diamond in the center looks like a high crowned OEC to me.

Yes, OEC!! Just shy of 5ct, in the setting it’s 17mm overall, but apparently the setting is very delicately made

 

[twosanguinehearts]

 

[YadaYadaYada]

Dead

 

[twosanguinehearts]

What's the metal? I think of lighter, more delicate, and more open work on the face-up side -- and in platinum. The gallery is pretty but what does the top look like (and, I guess, what is the name that grown-ups use for the "top")?

This is platinum!

 

[RRfromR]

Wow

 

[LightBright]

Here’s a 1910 “Edwardian” that has the fishtail design around the outer edge of the halo. it has an Arts And Crafts style shoulder and shank design (slightly Art Nouveau style). This ring does not look Edwardian to me but does have that fishtail pattern.

Your ring looks much more technical with perfect symmetry, suggesting more modern construction techniques, later design. I don’t know what time period, it’s very rare to see such good craftsmanship post Edwardian but a few design details do not seem typical Of that period, for example the fishtail pattern. Maybe it is a mishmash of design elements? No idea of when this ring could have been made.

Edwardian Double Halo Old Mine Cut Diamond Ring

Edwardian double halo ring with around approximately 1.5 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond center stone and old mine cut diamonds surrounding it. The diamonds are set in silver on 18k gold. Circa 1910. Size 7, can be sized.

www.bellandbird.com

 

[twosanguinehearts]

So interesting. I really want an original antique stone and setting, so some of this analysis does give me pause. It’s being sold as such, but now I have doubt…

 

[twosanguinehearts]

I love the OEC, too - estimated O/P in color and very bright edge to edge!

 

[LightBright]

Is it possible that it was made in Europe? Does it have a platinum mark (what does it say) or other marks? For example if it’s French I know they stamp the outside of the shank, not inside, etc. To me, the craftsmanship looks like bygone era, top notch. Not a recent modern replica.

 

[twosanguinehearts]

Is it possible that it was made in Europe? Does it have a platinum mark (what does it say) or other marks? For example if it’s French I know they stamp the outside of the shank, not inside, etc. To me, the craftsmanship looks like bygone era, top notch. Not a recent modern replica.

Good point, I will ask about this!!

 

[LightBright]

I wonder if it is an Argentinian made replica? Just throwing it out there. That is plausible.

The center stone is extremely well cut, it could be antique or replica, plausibly.

About five years ago I went to a Brick and Mortar jewelry store in a touristy East Coast town that specialized in antique jewelry. 80% of their pieces were old stones with replica settings. The owner told me the settings were ordered newly made Edwardian style, from Argentina. I was very surprised at how well crafted and how nicely designed they were. They totally fooled me (until I asked).

One thing you see on real Edwardian platinum rings is wear marks from where someone wore other rings next to it. They also don’t look “machine level” perfect in symmetry and construction. There are still some flaws as they were designed on paper and hand forged.

In spite of all I‘ve said here, this ring looks really gorgeous to me. It was done by someone with “mad skills”.

 

[Ally T]

Hi! I’m considering an original antique diamond ring and wondering what era it might be from? Seller isn’t 100% sure. Edwardian is my best guess but would love to get your thoughts. I typically prefer Victorian jewelry but this one caught my eye. Thank you!

Just off topic, as I have no idea when it comes to what you’re asking really, but that first picture shows a wonky set centre stone. It looks sunken on one side & lifted on the other, almost like its been placed in the setting. Please check it’s secure before purchasing.

 

[LightBright]

Just off topic, as I have no idea when it comes to what you’re asking really, but that first picture shows a wonky set centre stone. It looks sunken on one side & lifted on the other, almost like its been placed in the setting. Please check it’s secure before purchasing.

i agree, it’s a loose stone placed on top of the setting, tipped, not bezelled into the setting in that photo. Which makes me think the diamond and setting were not original together because I’m under the impression that you cannot unbezel a diamond from a halo without major damage.

 

[twosanguinehearts]

Just off topic, as I have no idea when it comes to what you’re asking really, but that first picture shows a wonky set centre stone. It looks sunken on one side & lifted on the other, almost like its been placed in the setting. Please check it’s secure before purchasing.

They did remove the stone to weigh it, I’m going to make sure it’s securely set if I spring for it!

 

[stepcutnut]

It is a lovely stone and setting, she has such an eye for finding gorgeous pieces I am sure it wouldn’t disappoint in person-good luck with your decision

 

[ItsMainelyYou]

Personal opinion, that's a really top quality replica. Incredibly well done, there's a sleekness to the lines that isn't present usually in the antique examples. At this level, honestly, who cares if it's actually Edwardian? The stone is fabulous. It's top workmanship in any time period.
I want to know who made it, because I want to know what else they can do. If they can do this kind of work? I want a mount from them.

 

[twosanguinehearts]

Thank you all for weighing in - I’m getting some additional closeups and will post tomorrow!!