shape
carat
color
clarity

Ideal halo ratio?

MissyBeaucoup

Brilliant_Rock
Premium
Joined
Mar 10, 2017
Messages
1,124
This is a question for those halo addicts out there, like @elle_71125 ...

What do you think is the ideal size for halo melee? If the stone is around 7 mm, is 1.3 mm about right, or do you prefer a chunkier look? How do you decide?

Halos tend to be expensive. Does the price tend to hold you back, or do you just go for the bigger size of bling? Did you ever get something so blingy that you wound up wearing it less?

I I would love to hear your halo philosophy!
 

voce

Ideal_Rock
Joined
May 13, 2018
Messages
5,161
It really depends on the halo look you want. If you want more of a "frosted" look, then you'd use smaller stones.

There's also the consideration of the more stones you use, the higher the setting cost, hence why I would personally use 2mm melee for a 7mm stone, because I think 2mm and under the cost of the stone is more linear with ct wt than over.

There's also the consideration of finger coverage and whether you have enough "room" on your fingers for larger melee sizes.
 

MissyBeaucoup

Brilliant_Rock
Premium
Joined
Mar 10, 2017
Messages
1,124
Thanks, @voce ! My finger size is a 5, so 2 mm seems nice and chunky to me.
 

T L

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Sep 20, 2008
Messages
25,156
This is a question for those halo addicts out there, like @elle_71125 ...

Did you ever get something so blingy that you wound up wearing it less?

I never ever had that problem:lol:

One of my favorite halos ever, well it’s a tie, is Elizabeth Taylor’s ruby ring and her emerald broach/pendant. The diamonds in them are enormous in proportion to the center stone, and yes, I know those world class gems can stand up to such a halo. Therefore, my philosophy is that it depends on the gem. Would I put a poorly colored gem in a super blingy huge halo, no way, it would get lost further. A gorgeous gem will stand up to any such halo, no matter the size. I have a teeny tiny half carat tsavorite in a large halo that looks like a snowflake. The color is probably top quality for tsavorite, but the gem still pops. Likewise, there are some gems I own that don’t have halos I consider worthy of their beauty, so I would love to reset them!!

Ahhhh dreams! Of course I love halos. I would halo my house if I could. They’re not everyone’s cup of tea, so if someone dislikes halos, they’ll never suggest one. You ultimately have to like them.

As a side note, halos do tend to be expensive if you use nice white diamonds, but other melee can be very cost effective like other colored gems, white zircon, etc...
 

elle_71125

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jan 29, 2012
Messages
6,194
“The bigger the hoop the bigger the hoe.” :mrgreen2:

Ok, that doesn’t exactly work with this question but it was the first thing that popped into my head so... :P2 Personally, I like diamond melee to be a little bigger. 1.3 is too small for me. 1.5 is usually my minimum but I really love a nice blingy halo so 2+mm is a-ok in my book. It really just depends what look you’re going for.

Ps. I’ve never gotten anything too blingy. My pink spinel ring was actually way more blingy than I expected and I rock that baby even more because of it. I’ll definitely be getting a larger halo again! :cool2:

Now because I’m supposed to be cleaning my house (and therefore doing anything else sounds like a lot more fun), here’s some of my rings with halo size details. :mrgreen2:

This one is a 1.5mm melee on a 6mm stone.
EF5A504C-5E21-4333-BD2C-E845E0D2A1A4.jpeg

1.5mm melee in a 9mm stone
D885FBCC-57AE-4086-9B6D-AF76C55960C6.jpeg

1.7mm melee on a 6x7mm stone
8DC0C1BD-FA3C-4270-B282-80DFF8AB165C.jpeg

2.0mm melee on a 6x5mm stone
F2C94D8A-4872-4090-A876-F37B15FA33B9.jpeg

2.4mm melee on a 7.1x5.5mm stone
944E48E1-3411-45A0-90F5-B2E19BFC0398.jpeg
 

T L

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Sep 20, 2008
Messages
25,156
Oh my goodness!! Such gorgeous halos Elle!! I think when most people think of a halo, they just think of diamonds in a simple curve around a stone, but yours are such creative and beautiful designs, worthy frames of such gorgeous gems.
 

MissyBeaucoup

Brilliant_Rock
Premium
Joined
Mar 10, 2017
Messages
1,124
Thanks so much for the advice, @T L and @elle_71125 ! And the gorgeous eye candy!!! It really helps me imagine the sizes better. So often jewelers just give the total weight of the diamonds and it’s really hard to compare.

I love your collection, Elle! So inspiring!
 

Atwater

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
May 11, 2010
Messages
515
“The bigger the hoop the bigger the hoe.” :mrgreen2:

Ok, that doesn’t exactly work with this question but it was the first thing that popped into my head so... :P2 Personally, I like diamond melee to be a little bigger. 1.3 is too small for me. 1.5 is usually my minimum but I really love a nice blingy halo so 2+mm is a-ok in my book. It really just depends what look you’re going for.

Ps. I’ve never gotten anything too blingy. My pink spinel ring was actually way more blingy than I expected and I rock that baby even more because of it. I’ll definitely be getting a larger halo again! :cool2:

Now because I’m supposed to be cleaning my house (and therefore doing anything else sounds like a lot more fun), here’s some of my rings with halo size details. :mrgreen2:

This one is a 1.5mm melee on a 6mm stone.
EF5A504C-5E21-4333-BD2C-E845E0D2A1A4.jpeg

1.5mm melee in a 9mm stone
D885FBCC-57AE-4086-9B6D-AF76C55960C6.jpeg

1.7mm melee on a 6x7mm stone
8DC0C1BD-FA3C-4270-B282-80DFF8AB165C.jpeg

2.0mm melee on a 6x5mm stone
F2C94D8A-4872-4090-A876-F37B15FA33B9.jpeg

2.4mm melee on a 7.1x5.5mm stone
944E48E1-3411-45A0-90F5-B2E19BFC0398.jpeg

Wow, beautiful and unique! You are both adventurous and creative.
 

elle_71125

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jan 29, 2012
Messages
6,194
Oh my goodness!! Such gorgeous halos Elle!! I think when most people think of a halo, they just think of diamonds in a simple curve around a stone, but yours are such creative and beautiful designs, worthy frames of such gorgeous gems.
Thank you very much! That’s high praise indeed! :love:

Thanks so much for the advice, @T L and @elle_71125 ! And the gorgeous eye candy!!! It really helps me imagine the sizes better. So often jewelers just give the total weight of the diamonds and it’s really hard to compare.

I love your collection, Elle! So inspiring!
Thank you! :mrgreen2:
Btw, there’s nothing I hate more than when jewelers just list the total carat weight. :wall:

Wow, beautiful and unique! You are both adventurous and creative.
Well, you’re just the sweetest. Thank you. :kiss2:
 

Sunshine812

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Jun 6, 2019
Messages
249
“The bigger the hoop the bigger the hoe.” :mrgreen2:

Ok, that doesn’t exactly work with this question but it was the first thing that popped into my head so... :P2 Personally, I like diamond melee to be a little bigger. 1.3 is too small for me. 1.5 is usually my minimum but I really love a nice blingy halo so 2+mm is a-ok in my book. It really just depends what look you’re going for.

Ps. I’ve never gotten anything too blingy. My pink spinel ring was actually way more blingy than I expected and I rock that baby even more because of it. I’ll definitely be getting a larger halo again! :cool2:

Now because I’m supposed to be cleaning my house (and therefore doing anything else sounds like a lot more fun), here’s some of my rings with halo size details. :mrgreen2:

This one is a 1.5mm melee on a 6mm stone.
EF5A504C-5E21-4333-BD2C-E845E0D2A1A4.jpeg

1.5mm melee in a 9mm stone
D885FBCC-57AE-4086-9B6D-AF76C55960C6.jpeg

1.7mm melee on a 6x7mm stone
8DC0C1BD-FA3C-4270-B282-80DFF8AB165C.jpeg

2.0mm melee on a 6x5mm stone
F2C94D8A-4872-4090-A876-F37B15FA33B9.jpeg

2.4mm melee on a 7.1x5.5mm stone
944E48E1-3411-45A0-90F5-B2E19BFC0398.jpeg

Hi, someone sent me your halos to look at referencing the size of melees in a halo around the center diamond. I must admit I fell in love with your last 2 rings, the 2.0mm melee on a 6x5mm stone and the 2.4mm melee on a 7.1x5.5 mm stone. They are absolutely gorgeous. Would you mind providing me with pics of the rings on all sides and underneath, possibly the renders if you have them? Anything at all would help. The reason I’m asking is I have now gone thru 3 renditions of a halo and in the renders the ring looks perfect but when the actual is made it doesn’t look anything like the render. It’s been such a let down. Here are my pics,

1st render
0FC96D0C-A884-4616-AE0B-24F249C83B9F.jpeg
1st ring
9C7E141F-111B-4384-95A7-ABE542EF7BF3.jpeg

2d render
E73D4158-50F8-452E-9703-AD106336FEB0.jpeg
2d ring
A8542704-A686-4045-8B9A-3CD0C441FC89.jpeg

3d render
3D2D044F-D390-4759-A09D-47C449FCEE61.jpeg
3d ring
D8EF58F6-54CB-4310-9483-DC2E6229E2AB.jpeg

as you can see, I’m having issues, I too like the chunkier melees in my halo, the problem I think I have is they are not big enough melees and the design of ring is not correct.
i would like some info please. Thank you
 

Attachments

  • EC47AFC7-EC75-40F1-9550-4B3D27A94206.jpeg
    EC47AFC7-EC75-40F1-9550-4B3D27A94206.jpeg
    209.8 KB · Views: 36

elle_71125

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jan 29, 2012
Messages
6,194
Hi, someone sent me your halos to look at referencing the size of melees in a halo around the center diamond. I must admit I fell in love with your last 2 rings, the 2.0mm melee on a 6x5mm stone and the 2.4mm melee on a 7.1x5.5 mm stone. They are absolutely gorgeous. Would you mind providing me with pics of the rings on all sides and underneath, possibly the renders if you have them? Anything at all would help. The reason I’m asking is I have now gone thru 3 renditions of a halo and in the renders the ring looks perfect but when the actual is made it doesn’t look anything like the render. It’s been such a let down. Here are my pics,

1st render
0FC96D0C-A884-4616-AE0B-24F249C83B9F.jpeg
1st ring
9C7E141F-111B-4384-95A7-ABE542EF7BF3.jpeg

2d render
E73D4158-50F8-452E-9703-AD106336FEB0.jpeg
2d ring
A8542704-A686-4045-8B9A-3CD0C441FC89.jpeg

3d render
3D2D044F-D390-4759-A09D-47C449FCEE61.jpeg
3d ring
D8EF58F6-54CB-4310-9483-DC2E6229E2AB.jpeg

as you can see, I’m having issues, I too like the chunkier melees in my halo, the problem I think I have is they are not big enough melees and the design of ring is not correct.
i would like some info please. Thank you

I’m going to reply to you in your other thread.
 

Member23

Rough_Rock
Joined
Nov 3, 2021
Messages
24
@MissyBeaucoup: for a 7mm round stone with a simple round halo, here is how it would look with different sizes of melee:
Capture.JPG

This is awesome! I have a question regarding stones and width. I’m currently planning to get a halo pave engagement ring with a 2.0mm band width. Do you think 1.8mm stones surrounding the center diamond and on the sides would be appropriate for a center stone with a diameter of 6.5mm (1.06ct round brilliant)?
 

2Neezers

Brilliant_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jan 8, 2014
Messages
1,874
This is awesome! I have a question regarding stones and width. I’m currently planning to get a halo pave engagement ring with a 2.0mm band width. Do you think 1.8mm stones surrounding the center diamond and on the sides would be appropriate for a center stone with a diameter of 6.5mm (1.06ct round brilliant)?

I have a ruby ring with a similar center stone to halo ratio. The ruby is 6.4mm and the halo melee are 1.7mm. Here it is on a size 8 finger..please ignore my dry & puffy hand ;-). 91FF2FB5-32DB-4E1A-AFCF-046C7A5359CE.jpeg
 

Member23

Rough_Rock
Joined
Nov 3, 2021
Messages
24
I have a ruby ring with a similar center stone to halo ratio. The ruby is 6.4mm and the halo melee are 1.7mm. Here it is on a size 8 finger..please ignore my dry & puffy hand ;-). 91FF2FB5-32DB-4E1A-AFCF-046C7A5359CE.jpeg

Do you feel like the stones are too big? Would you rather go smaller?
 

2Neezers

Brilliant_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jan 8, 2014
Messages
1,874
Do you feel like the stones are too big? Would you rather go smaller?

The diamonds are big, but I was going for the look of more of a diamond cluster halo style with this ring. I would go definitely go smaller if you are looking to have the center stone be the focal point of the ring.
 

Member23

Rough_Rock
Joined
Nov 3, 2021
Messages
24
The diamonds are big, but I was going for the look of more of a diamond cluster halo style with this ring. I would go definitely go smaller if you are looking to have the center stone be the focal point of the ring.

Do you have anything in mind? I want the band to be 2.0mm in width from what I've read regarding stability and thickness. However, that means the diamonds must be 1.8mm. If I go with 1.5mm/1.3mm surrounding the halo, would you say that it'd look weird?
 

2Neezers

Brilliant_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jan 8, 2014
Messages
1,874
Do you have anything in mind? I want the band to be 2.0mm in width from what I've read regarding stability and thickness. However, that means the diamonds must be 1.8mm. If I go with 1.5mm/1.3mm surrounding the halo, would you say that it'd look weird?

What type of stone will your center stone be? If it’s a diamond, the 1.8mm halo stones will have a more fluid look next to the center stone. Also, my halo is framed by metal. If the halo diamonds are the type that are set without a metal border, the halo will look a bit smaller. Do you have an inspiration picture of a ring with the look you would like to have for your own ring? Halo stone size is such a personal preference, it would help to see the look you’re going for :)) .
 

Member23

Rough_Rock
Joined
Nov 3, 2021
Messages
24
What type of stone will your center stone be? If it’s a diamond, the 1.8mm halo stones will have a more fluid look next to the center stone. Also, my halo is framed by metal. If the halo diamonds are the type that are set without a metal border, the halo will look a bit smaller. Do you have an inspiration picture of a ring with the look you would like to have for your own ring? Halo stone size is such a personal preference, it would help to see the look you’re going for :)) .

The center stone will be a natural mind round brilliant diamond. It’s 6.5mm in diameter (1.06ct). He is making an “example” band to see how it’ll look like, but honestly I want a halo that’ll enhance the center without the side diamonds overpowering it!
 

2Neezers

Brilliant_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jan 8, 2014
Messages
1,874
The center stone will be a natural mind round brilliant diamond. It’s 6.5mm in diameter (1.06ct). He is making an “example” band to see how it’ll look like, but honestly I want a halo that’ll enhance the center without the side diamonds overpowering it!

A model/example ring should help! That will also give you more time to look at pictures and nail down the halo size you’d like.
 

CaseyLouLou

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Dec 22, 2019
Messages
1,257
“The bigger the hoop the bigger the hoe.” :mrgreen2:

Ok, that doesn’t exactly work with this question but it was the first thing that popped into my head so... :P2 Personally, I like diamond melee to be a little bigger. 1.3 is too small for me. 1.5 is usually my minimum but I really love a nice blingy halo so 2+mm is a-ok in my book. It really just depends what look you’re going for.

Ps. I’ve never gotten anything too blingy. My pink spinel ring was actually way more blingy than I expected and I rock that baby even more because of it. I’ll definitely be getting a larger halo again! :cool2:

Now because I’m supposed to be cleaning my house (and therefore doing anything else sounds like a lot more fun), here’s some of my rings with halo size details. :mrgreen2:

This one is a 1.5mm melee on a 6mm stone.
EF5A504C-5E21-4333-BD2C-E845E0D2A1A4.jpeg

1.5mm melee in a 9mm stone
D885FBCC-57AE-4086-9B6D-AF76C55960C6.jpeg

1.7mm melee on a 6x7mm stone
8DC0C1BD-FA3C-4270-B282-80DFF8AB165C.jpeg

2.0mm melee on a 6x5mm stone
F2C94D8A-4872-4090-A876-F37B15FA33B9.jpeg

2.4mm melee on a 7.1x5.5mm stone
944E48E1-3411-45A0-90F5-B2E19BFC0398.jpeg

May I please ask who made your rings? Thanks!
 

CaseyLouLou

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Dec 22, 2019
Messages
1,257
They were all made by David Klass. He & his team do excellent work. :mrgreen:

I have used him a couple of times so that’s great that he can make me one of these at some point! Thanks.
 

auburngirl06

Rough_Rock
Joined
Oct 18, 2021
Messages
40
The center stone will be a natural mind round brilliant diamond. It’s 6.5mm in diameter (1.06ct). He is making an “example” band to see how it’ll look like, but honestly I want a halo that’ll enhance the center without the side diamonds overpowering it!

I am working on a new setting for my 1 carat RB and I am trying to decide on the same thing. I have confirmed a 2mm band is the size diamonds I want but I’m not sure about the halo melee. My jeweler today said he wouldn’t recommend 1.5mm halo with 2mm band as it may look disproportionate. I don’t know what to do.

I’m following to see if you get a rendering to look at!
 
Be a part of the community Get 3 HCA Results
Top