I need some help!

[italianstallion]

I purchased a 1ct pricess cut diamond on a cathedral mounted band. When I originally looked at this diamond they only had a little paper copy of the cert (EGL Cert) that had all the specs. The specs on the little paper copy read as below:

1ct
Measurements: 5.54x5.16x3.98
Proportion: Very Good
Depth 77.1%
Table 77%
Girdle: THICK
Finish Grade: VERY GOOD
Purity: SI1
Color: G
PRICE: 3,800.00 (including the platinum cathedral mount band)

Ends up that they couldn't find the original cert and had to send it back to EGL to get re-certified. The specs below are from the new cert from EGL:

1ct
Measurements: 5.15x5.53x4.05
Depth 78.50%
Table 72.70%
Crown 9.50%
Pavillion 43.50%
Girdle: EX THIN TO EX THICk POLISHED
Cutlet: NONE
Polish: GOOD
Symmetry: GOOD
Clarity SI2
Color: G
Fluorescence: NONE

Somehow the clarity went from a SI1 to a SI2 and the measurements do not match. I need to know if I ended up with a better stone then what I paid for or did I get ripped off? What is the ideal price for the diamond with the new specs versus the old specs? Any help is greatly appreciated!

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

Does not look good to me.

Go back.

re the price - it is not relevant as there is no "ideal price".
What is the right price for a wool sweater?

 

[oldminer]

I think they gave you a different diamond on the second go round. Maybe it was the diamond you saw the first time and maybe they have changed diamonds on you. Neither one is anything special in terms of CUT, but there is no reason to accept a lower clarity for the same money you spent.