I can't decide between these 2 diamonds!

[Tuxtax]

I can't decide between these two diamonds, and I have been thinking between these two for too long. Please tell me your thoughts.

Here are the two GIA reports.

Option 1: G, VS2, Excellent Cut, 1.85 carat

Option 2: I, VS1, Excellent Cut, 1.90 carat

I will choose a platinum setting.

I like the G color diamond a lot except the feather still bothers me, even though I read a lot of posts here about feathers not being too much of a problem at the VS2 level.

I like the I color diamond for what I perceive for its durability since it has no feathers.

Also, based on the metrics, it looks like the G color diamond has more fire / sparkle??? Am I correct?

Which would you choose?

Thanks a lot!

 

[Kaycee2018]

The cut of the 1.85ct G is "safer", but the report is from 2013. I'd go with that one, but would want them to send it to GIA for a new report to confirm it is in the same condition.

 

[Tuxtax]

Oh wow, why would the 1.85 G be safer in your opinion? I thought feathers are more durability issues.

 

[Big Fat Facets]

of the 2 options, I would go with the g color 1.85 carat.