Hi Karl_K and everyone else!

[Tennismom]

I was reading the thread from novice diamond girl and didn't want to thread jack. My jeweler has a stone which has the proportions that you said would be better for her.

56 table
35.5 crown angle, 15.5%
40.6 pavilion angle, 42.5%
62.6 depth
60% stars
80% lg
Thin to slightly thick (faceted) 4.5%

It gets a 1.4 HCA
1B AGA
When I check the GIA tables it scores in the excellent range for table,crown,pavilion angles but I think that the stars are making it score Very Good cut grade. Just a guess from everything that i have been reading.Excellent polish and again Very Good symmetry. Any insight would be very helpful to me. He is looking at the stone, not me and recommends it. I just have pictures.
Thanks .

 

[diamondseeker2006]

62.6 is deeper than we normally recommend. What is the weight of the stone and what is the diameter? Is the stone not GIA graded?

 

[Tennismom]

Hi Diamond Seeker, yes it has a GIA report. It is 7.65 and 1.76.

 

[Sakuracherry]

It is cut deep. Thus, the face up size might be smaller than what you excpect.

 

[Karl_K]

The angles should work together and the pic look like they do.
However there is a bit of weight lost in the girdle so it faces up a bit small.

If you have other images post them.

 

[Tennismom]

One more picture. What happens with 60% stars with those other proportions? What would keep this from being an excellent?Thanks for looking and for your valued opinion.

 

[Karl_K]

60% stars are fine, it would show in the pic if it was an issue