
Last edited:
What's the site to generate those comparisons?
I agree with the others, you really won’t be able to see the size difference between a .91 and a 1.01 carat and it’s crazy how that “magic” 1 carat mark means so many extra dollars.
Remember to consider different sizes as a % increase. A .50 carat diamond compared to a 1.0 carat is 100% bigger or double size but a 1.0 carat to a 1.5 carat is only 66% bigger.
I would keep saving and aim for a 1.20 carat down the track.
Also, you could easily get more than $2,000 for a .91 carat diamond if you sell it privately.
What's the site to generate those comparisons?
OP, I'm not sure what your budget is, but this is a spready stone for a very good price (less than $8K!), and it just almost hits the 6.8 mm mark! It's still very white at G color, is eye clean VS2, and is cut much better than your current stone (you should be looking for at LEAST GIA XXX, as Very Good and Good aren't very good at all). Fluorescence is a bonus (as it would give a cool affect and make it appear even whiter in certain lighting environments... it doesn't appear to negatively affect the stone, but would need to be verified).
https://www.jamesallen.com/loose-di...g-color-vs2-clarity-excellent-cut-sku-5402539
I show you this as an example of the money that can be saved by going just a bit down in color. This was actually a lot cleaner than your SI2. I also mention this stone to show how the diameter (size) of same ct weight stones can vary a good bit.
Check this out... go down to H/SI1 (still looks eye clean to me) and you can save another $1K ($6980). The specs are extremely similar to the G/VS2 (you'd just need the rep to double check the effect of the SBF to make sure it has no negative effects). This stone is even LARGER, just almost hitting the 6.9 mm mark -- now THAT would be a HUGE difference in size (22%!!) from your current stone. (both stones scored 0.8 on the HCA) I actually like the angles on this one better than the G because it has a smaller table and higher crown angle.
https://www.jamesallen.com/loose-di...h-color-si1-clarity-excellent-cut-sku-5370840
6.23 x 6.19 vs 6.89 x 6.85 mm
Again, don't know your budget, so this is just an example.
Agree with the logic but not in love with a 32.5 CA and 41.0 PA combo. Technically it hits ideal zone on the AGS charts, depending how GIA averaged the values.
By the way if size is the ONLY reason you are upgrading from .9 to 1.10 then I might wait. But I see a table of 60 and depth of 62.3 in combo with VG polish and symmetry and SI2 clarity and think you could benefit on multiple facets.
Although the 60/60 style is preferred by some also
Update: I have been in contact with my original vendor, a rep from Diamonds Direct, and a private diamond dealer recommended from an acquaintance. I'm still waiting on the first 2 to get me more info, but the private diamond dealer sent me a spreadsheet of several diamond options. I have chosen 3 that I am interested in seeing in person. The thing is, none of them are certified AT ALL. He said they are "graded by GIA standards" (by whom?). I asked him if we could meet at a brick and mortar jeweler to verify that they are what he says they are and he agreed. I don't require that they be certified since I doubt I'll ever upgrade after this..I just want to be sure that they are actually diamonds and are of the grade he claims they are. I don't really have a local jeweler, do they even do this service for stones not purchased from them (for a fee I would assume). Also, do these 3 look like good options? The price listed would be after the trade in, and they are all round brilliants.
A) Size: 1.21ct
Color:H
Clarity:SI2
Cut, polish, symmetry all excellent
Fluorescence: faint
Depth: 58.2%
Measurements: 7-7.06x4.08
Price: $1190+tax
B) Size:1.21ct
Color:H
Clarity:SI2
Cut, polish, symmetry all excellent
Fluorescence: faint
Depth: 61.9%
Measurements:6.85-6.86x4.24
Price: $1,365+tax
C) Size: 1.15ct
Color:E
Clarity:SI2
Cut, polish, symmetry all excellent
Fluorescence:none
Depth:61%
Measurements: 6.75-6.75x4
Price: $1600+tax
What do you guys think about these? @msop04 @Luce @Wink @Bron357
And anyone else who wants to chime in!
Thanks!
No true hurry, but it would take me a very long time to save up $8K for a whole new diamond and not so long to save up $2k...also I have no need for my original diamond so I would rather trade it...I don't think I would wear it as a pendant, it's too small. I'm still waiting to hear from the other 2 vendors though...I still vote to wait and save up for a bigger upgrade or get something from a pricescope vendor or that has been vetted by pricescope members. All of this private diamond dealer concierge business and unpapered diamonds that have no images and whatnot isn't something I can help you with. And remember, you have to give them your stone and pay up to $2k.
Exciting prospect, but what's the hurry?
Update: I have been in contact with my original vendor, a rep from Diamonds Direct, and a private diamond dealer recommended from an acquaintance. I'm still waiting on the first 2 to get me more info, but the private diamond dealer sent me a spreadsheet of several diamond options. I hav e chosen 3 that I am interested in seeing in person. The thing is, none of them are certified AT ALL. He said they are "graded by GIA standards" (by whom?). I asked him if we could meet at a brick and mortar jeweler to verify that they are what he says they are and he agreed. I don't require that they be certified since I doubt I'll ever upgrade after this..I just want to be sure that they are actually diamonds and are of the grade he claims they are. I don't really have a local jeweler, do they even do this service for stones not purchased from them (for a fee I would assume). Also, do these 3 look like good options? The price listed would be after the trade in, and they are all round brilliants.
A) Size: 1.21ct
Color:H
Clarity:SI2
Cut, polish, symmetry all excellent
Fluorescence: faint
Depth: 58.2%
Measurements: 7-7.06x4.08
Price: $1190+tax
B) Size:1.21ct
Color:H
Clarity:SI2
Cut, polish, symmetry all excellent
Fluorescence: faint
Depth: 61.9%
Measurements:6.85-6.86x4.24
Price: $1,365+tax
C) Size: 1.15ct
Color:E
Clarity:SI2
Cut, polish, symmetry all excellent
Fluorescence:none
Depth:61%
Measurements: 6.75-6.75x4
Price: $1600+tax
What do you guys think about these? Thanks!
Thanks for your input. You guys have convinced me to stay away from the private diamond dealer...but to your point about the SI 2 grading, my current diamond is SI 2 and has a bubble and a feather that I saw under microscope but is completely eye clean to me no matter how hard I look at itDo you trust these people? I only ask because you are talking NON-CERTIFIED stones that are SI2 clarity to top it off. Most SI2's are not eye clean, and need to be fully vetted to ensure they are acceptable.
Also to even have a shot at giving you any sort of advise, we need the crown & pavilion angles along with the table size of each stone.
I do know that looking at depths only, stone A @ 58% is cut too shallow. Not knowing the angles of stones B & C make it difficult to say much more about them but the depths look okay. I would say that if you have an F now, then you may not be happy with an H color (stone B) depending how color sensitive you are.
Edited to Add:
Some posts got added while I was typing this response. So with your $2k trade + your existing diamond you are going to have $8k or so invested in a NON-CERTIFIED 1.2ct stone? I'll be honest, I don't love this deal. I know it's not this simple as you have to work around a trade-in; however, here are just a few SUPER IDEALS you could get with full certifications and guaranteed superb cuts.
https://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/round-cut-loose-diamond-4006534.htm
https://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/round-cut-loose-diamond-3986332.htm
https://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/round-cut-loose-diamond-3965464.htm
https://www.briangavindiamonds.com/...ls/1.235-h-si1-round-diamond-ags-104090738005
https://www.briangavindiamonds.com/...1.162-h-vs2-round-diamond-ags-bl-104100412081
Y'all are so helpful, than you for all the recommendations and visuals! I have to admit, I really don't know what a lot of these specs mean beyond the basic C's and measurements. GOOD NEWS, though! I spoke with someone else from the vendor my diamond was purchased from, and the 50% policy doesn't go into effect until next year! Their current policy is to buy my diamond back at the original price I paid and I just need to go up in price for any other stone. I realize that it still may not be the best deal with inflation costs, but I'll have to see what they come up with. When I get some specs on some stones I will post here to get all your expert advice! Thanks everyone!![]()