Help on Princess cut selection please

[spurnoff]

Hi all. I'm after some input to find out if I'm on the right track. I'm hoping to narrow these diamonds down to 3 so I can get an ASET images. I'm after a 1crt princess cut with a color of at least an F as it's going to be in a platinum setting and my partner somehow noticed the difference with the G and didn't like it.
Now I've come up with these diamonds based on searching for 1crt diamonds that have similar table and depth to the ACA selection from Whiteflash and narrowed the selection down from there as I figured that was a good base to work from. The ACA diamonds seem to have a depth of 73-75 and a table of 68-71. The obvious difference to me is that the ACA selection seems to all have 3 chevrons whilst the ones I'm finding have 4. I'm guessing if 1 of these diamonds is a real dud the rest will be because I've chosen them with very similar parameters but I'll post them all anyway. Budget is about 5k, worst comes to worse and I'll end up getting the ACA for $5750.
Am I on the right track?

diamond 1 $4440
Shape: Princess
carat weight: 1.01
color: F
clarity: VS2
polish: Excellent
symmetry: Very Good
Fluorescence: None
l/w/d (mm): 5.38*5.40*4.06
l/w ratio: 1.00
depth %: 75.40
girdle: Medium - Slightly Thick
table %: 70.00
certificate: GIA
diamond 2 $4590
Shape: Princess
carat weight: 1.01
color: F
clarity: VS2
polish: Excellent
symmetry: Very Good
Fluorescence: None
l/w/d (mm): 5.39*5.35*4.00
l/w ratio: 1.01
depth %: 74.80
girdle: Thick - Very Thick
table %: 69.00
certificate: GIA
diamond 3 $4750
Shape: Princess
carat weight: 1.00
color: F
clarity: VS2
polish: Excellent
symmetry: Very Good
Fluorescence: None
l/w/d (mm): 5.41*5.39*4.07
l/w ratio: 1.00
depth %: 75.50
girdle: Medium - Thick
table %: 70.00
certificate: GIA
diamond 4 $4820
Shape: Princess
carat weight: 1.01
color: F
clarity: VS1
polish: Excellent
symmetry: Very Good
Fluorescence: None
l/w/d (mm): 5.40*5.37*3.99
l/w ratio: 1.01
depth %: 74.30
girdle: Thick - Very Thick
table %: 71.00
culet: None
certificate: GIA
crown ∠: 44.92
crown %: 10.24
pavilion ∠: 40.42
pavilion %: 60.03
diamond 5 $4890
Shape: Princess
carat weight: 1.00
color: F
clarity: VS2
polish: Excellent
symmetry: Very Good
Fluorescence: None
l/w/d (mm): 5.49*5.42*3.99
l/w ratio: 1.01
depth %: 73.60
girdle: Slightly Thick - Thick
table %: 70.00
diamond 6 $5140
Shape: Princess
carat weight: 1.00
color: F
clarity: VS2
polish: Excellent
symmetry: Very Good
Fluorescence: None
l/w/d (mm): 5.41*5.39*4.07
l/w ratio: 1.00
depth %: 75.50
girdle: Medium - Thick
table %: 70.00
culet: None
certificate: GIA

 

[spurnoff]

Bump, does anyone have any advice?

 

[OoohShiny]

The ASET images will be the key determining factor, I think, and unfortunately there is no equivalent HCA tool for Princess cuts, so you may just have to take a punt on which look good in any 'normal' pictures.

I am no expert, though

 

[SpencerDane]

Princess cut diamonds have always been my favorite. While I am not an expert either, in my opinion, the diamond that is $4750 is the most stunning of them all. I looked at all the pictures and I adjusted the zoom on each. This one just has a breathtaking sparkle that makes it more beautiful than the rest.