shape
carat
color
clarity

Help me find the "perfect" diamond!! Princess or Cushion.

Fedor_King

Rough_Rock
Joined
Mar 20, 2014
Messages
2
Hi Guys,

Been following this forum for about a month trying to get educated. Seems like the more I know about diamonds, the less I know about diamonds. I do know that my SO loves Square diamonds. We have particualarly been looking at Cushions/ Princess but she is possibly open to other square cuts.

The total budget is about ~10K, this includes the setting.

The setting we found is by Jeff Cooper for $2,800 and the website we were looking at offers about $1K off the diamond when we buy this particular setting, which she happens to really like.

This is where the trouble begins. The ideal diamond is 1.5 carat, G, VS2, and has to have an amazing cut. However, this criteria seems 30-40% over the budget.

We have been looking at only GIA/AGS diamonds as we have read that EGL is not reputable. Can EGL USA be trusted in their grading-- there is some mixed commentary regarding this.

So now we need some creative ideas.

Should we be looking at H-I-J diamonds with flourecense? We both seem to like whiter diamonds in general. What are some tips to find diamonds that appear larger/ whiter face-up?

Should we look at SI1 diamonds and call the dealers to confirm they are eye-clean? How can we trust that when so many diamonds are drop-shipped?

Lastly, if you were me with 10K budget (roughly 8K) for diamond-- WHAT WOULD YOU BUY TODAY?

Any links greatly appreciated!!

Thanks!
 
Re: Help me find the "perfect" diamond!! Princess or Cushion

Wow thanks for the links. I have never considered fancy colors-- not so sure SO would like them.

The Brian Gavin one looks insanely good. How is this one a I color that looks whiter than most G colors I have seen in real life. What I am missing?

Also, is it fromt he experts, is it always worth forgoing Color and Clarity to get the top of the line cut (ACA, Hearts & Arrows, Signature cuts) etc. etc.?

Thanks!
 
Re: Help me find the "perfect" diamond!! Princess or Cushion

Both of those August Vintage Cushions are top of the line cuts :love:
 
Re: Help me find the "perfect" diamond!! Princess or Cushion

Pattern/Scintillation is what we need to know, do you like broad reflecting facets or lots or little sparkly facets,
Hearts and Arrows gives you the symmetrical pattern in the cushion if that is what you like, the august vintage has large facets that form a maltese cross, Its about personal preference when it comes to pattern no one is superior.
Optics/proportions determine light return but both August vintage and the Brian gavin cushions have top class optics so no need to worry there.

So first determine the pattern or look you are after then we can help you .
 
Re: Help me find the "perfect" diamond!! Princess or Cushion

I absolutely adore AVC's, but if she wants a more modern cushion, there are some of those, too:

http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/10439/ (price is $7121)

http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/9290/

http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/9911/

http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/11241/

I am guessing the setting is more modern, and if so, I'd go with a modern cushion over a princess.

Here is a higher color AVC:

http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/11353/
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top