Help me choose princess e-ring

[legonza4]

Hello,

This is my first post on Pricescope and I hope to choose an e-ring for my gf! I have read many posts and have learned more than I could imagine from you all. Thus, my hope is that you can help me choose now that the time is right for me. Cut is most important to me, I would prefer a G over H but not entirely opposed to H if it faces up white (which I have confirmation that this one does). My budget is $4800

I have consulted a WF rep and I am about to put on hold. I would love to hear what you all think/if there is anything glaringly wrong with either of them. Thanks in advance!

Diamond 1:
Princess ACA
0.924 H VS2
Depth: 77.2, Table: 59.5
Measurements: 5.34x5.23x4.04
Girdle: Thin-Slightly thick
Ideal Scope:
ASET:

Diamond 2:
Princess ACA
0.91 G VS2
Depth: 74.8, Table 65.5
Measurements: 5.33-5.23x3.91
Girdle: Medium
Ideal Scope:
ASET:

In the event that I can't decide, how much weight would you put on the rep's evaluation of the diamonds after looking at them in person?

 

[RockyRacoon]

The stones you linked look good, but it may be beneficial to see some other options.

Check out this stone, right at your budget:
.92ct, G, VS2
http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/12036/

Here is another option, below budget:
.91ct, H, VVS2
http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/12035/


I would probably go for the GOG .92ct, G stone, as it is more square than the other stones, something which I prefer in princess cuts.

 

[legonza4]

Thank you for your reply and suggestions. I was hoping to stay with WF. Compared to Diamond 1 (the other H), do you think it would make a huge difference in terms of quality if I saved some $$ by going this route?

Diamond 3:
Princess ACA
0.907 H VS1
Depth: 76.8, Table: 69.5
Measurements: 5.18x5.17x3.97
Girdle: Medium-Slightly thick

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I would be happy with any princess ACA! They are ideal cut princess stones and among the best you can find!

The first two are a little larger, which is a plus, but the last one is more perfectly square which is nice. My tendency would be maybe to go for one of the larger ones.

 

[Lorelei]

I would be happy with any princess ACA! They are ideal cut princess stones and among the best you can find!

The first two are a little larger, which is a plus, but the last one is more perfectly square which is nice. My tendency would be maybe to go for one of the larger ones.

My thoughts echo our Seeker's here, all these Princess are superbly cut diamonds with good visual balance a priority. Your colour and clarity specs are just fine, all should be eye clean and white, I think just pick the one you like best. If you are unsure, ask one of the good chaps at WF to view each to discuss them with you, one of their experts will be able to tell you which stone has the most ' flair', or if one might be more suitable for your purposes than another.