Help Me choose one Please Help I have to decide today

[rro_reyes]

Guys what option you think is a better deal?

The website say both are CLEAN EYE.

Option two is expensive and smaller .806 with color F. Option one is bigger .876 but is SI2 than option two that is SI1 and H than option two that is F.

Option 1

http://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/princess-cut-loose-diamond-2803910.htm

Option 2

http://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/princess-cut-loose-diamond-2803921.htm

Please HELP me guys i need to decide today, max tommorrow.

If you think both are a bad deal also tell me

 

[Christina...]

I'm so happy that WF was able to find you a couple of options. If they are saying that both stones are eye clean then personally, I would go with the larger stone over the F color. You won't see a large color difference between F and G and you are paying a premium for F. So, I would go with what my eye can visually see and that will be the size difference. Squares tend to face up smaller than other cuts so I would want to maximize the size. You really can't go wrong with either choice though.

 

[rro_reyes]

The Whiteflash baseline definition of eye-clean is:
 
No inclusions visible to the naked eye of a person with 20/20 vision when viewing the diamond in the face-up position at a distance of approximately 10 inches under normal overhead lighting .
 
Distance, lighting and human vision all influence this judgment. There is no universally agreed upon definition of eye-clean in the trade so we developed this one in order to communicate meaningfully with our customers. 10 inches is the ‘distance of most distinct vision’ as defined by the field of optometry.  It is also a basis used by the AGS Laboratory in light performance grading, and so this is a logical standard and a practical baseline.

But im scared my gf and the people can see the inclusions. But i like is 500 usd cheaper and biger. This one is S2, the other is S1.

Wat do you think? Any more opinions thanks

 

[webdiva]

Imagine that huge diamond picture shrunk down to the tip of a pen - you can be reassured that you probably won't see any inclusions. However, you can order the larger one and return if you don't like it.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I'd go with the F SI1. The other one does not look clean enough for ME. But you may differ on the clarity you require!

 

[Christina...]

yeah, I was going to say the same as webdiva. Your talking about a 5.2mm stone, so I really don't think that you will see anything in the face up postition, however, you may be able to from the side view, depending on how you are setting the stone. Prongs will cover much of this view though. The inclusions all look white and you wont be looking at the stone from a distance much less than 10 inches anyway, surly no one else will be. If your gf is one that will sit at home and loupe the diamond looking for inclusions then you may want to stick with VS graded stones, because she will likely find the inclusions in an SI1 when louped as well.

This is an extremely well cut diamond with optimal light performance, my guess is that a novice wearer isn't going to be able to spot the inclusions and personally with WFs recommendation I would be willing to take the risk and have the stone sent to you for evaluation. I don't know your gfs priorities but given that they are both considered eye clean, I would go for the larger of the two, but I'm not significantly inclusion sensitive, so eye clean is clean enough for me.

 

[rro_reyes]

Thanks every one specially you Christina you are veryyy kind

Any more opinions friends ?.

 

[E B]

Do you have time to get and inspect the larger SI2 (and send it back if you can see the inclusions)? If so, go with that one.

If not (your first post sounds like you may be in a hurry?) I'd go with the F SI1. It sounds like it'd be more mind-clean to you and your girlfriend won't know the diamond you compared it to, only the one on her finger.

 

[rro_reyes]

Thanks for your answers friends

This is the VS2 diamons in the pic

The things that look like scartches are inclusions?


Regards

 

[TitanCi]

Yes and more than likely you won't see them. The pix are very magnified so that you CAN see them, but it's different when looking in profile view too. You might want to ask if the inclusions can be seen from the sides of the stones.

 

[rro_reyes]

I bought the SI2 .876 ct, I hope no regret.

Thanks everybody

 

[rro_reyes]

Hi friends. Whiteflash just send me pics of the diamond with settting, what do you sincerely thinks?

Regards

 

[E B]

It looks beautiful! Great choice.

 

[tyty333]

Looks great! More pics when you get it!

 

[Christina...]

I'm so excited for you! I'm so happy that you found a stone that you loved, it looks beautiful in the setting. She will be thrilled!! Be sure to take lots and lots of pictures when you get the ring and propose......we consider that our reward for all of our hard work! Just kidding, but we can't get enough photos and this ring is definitely worthy of it's own Show me the Bling thread!! Congratulations!!

 

[rro_reyes]

Jaja , of course Thanks for the help christine and everybody. Im going to take photos and upload soon.

Thanks