Help me again with ERD CADs! Halo Shape?

[tweeter8177]

Well, I got the third round of CADs. To me the halo shape still doesn't look like what I want, so I sent a compare picture to ERD (first picture). The response: "The rounded look as opposed to the flat look in reference to the halo is a visual element as they are at the same curve the difference is in the corners which actuate the cushion-y halo as opposed to the pointy halo."

So given that, I have to choose. I am sure it will turn out perfect but I am torn! Which shape do you prefer?
Also, I am attaching some of the other CAD pictures. Any other suggestions?

Thanks for all your opinions this far!





Inspiration Picture

 

[MarionC]

The rounded looks more modern/elegant to me and the square looks more like a vintage ring. Still pretty, but different feel.

 

[redroze]

I like the pointed halo as I like the vintage feel. BUT I think the took fed halo is closer to your inspiration so you should go with that one. It will look great either way!

 

[tweeter8177]

Thanks Redroze and Jimmianne for the comments! Looks like the votes are all rounded corners right now!

 

[Gypsy]

I like the pointed. It looks more unique to me (CAD 1).

 

[davidsbfly]

I also prefer the pointed one vs the rounded one. I love the vintage-y look! The inspiration photo I love too and looks a little less pointy.