Help Choosing 8-9 ct Emerald Cut Diamond

[teslagirl1234]

8.02 ASET.

 

[teslagirl1234]

9.07

 

[teslagirl1234]

9.07

@Karl_K do you prefer one of these from the ASET?

 

[Karl_K]

8ct has better ASET
9ct not enough light return under the table.

 

[teslagirl1234]

8ct has better ASET
9ct not enough light return under the table.

Thank you. I saw the same, just wanted confirmed by someone more experienced with Emerald cuts.

 

[Dreamer_D]

I would exclude the 9ct. The 8ct has good potential and looks nice in the second setting you showed. Maybe you can find better if you keep hunting but it’s got potential.

 

[teslagirl1234]

I would exclude the 9ct. The 8ct has good potential and looks nice in the second setting you showed. Maybe you can find better if you keep hunting but it’s got potential.

For a temporary stone to be upgraded to natural soon, the 8.02 ended up as the keeper. Any recommendations on those who will cut an amazing natural emerald cut, J+, VS+? Ideally at trade or close to trade pricing?

 

[Karl_K]

Try Yoram at https://gemconcepts.net/

Full disclosure. Yoram and I have partnered on some projects together.
He in my opinion is a premiere step cut cutter.(other types also)