Help choosing 3 carat diamond - HCA Score 1.4 or 1.9?

[bryanm]

I would like to hear some thoughts on these diamond specs...

DIAMOND 1
HCA Score 1.9
3.20 Carat
I Color
Measurements 9.35 x 9.40 x 5.84

Depth % 62.4
Table % 57
Crown Angle 36
Pavilion Angle 40.6
Crown % 15.5

Girdle 4% - Med to Slightly Thick Faceted
Star % 50
Lower Girdle % 80
Culet None


DIAMOND 2
HCA Score 1.4
3.01 Carat
H Color
Measurements 9.32 x 9.37 x 5.58

Depth % 59.8
Table % 59
Crown Angle 32
Pavilion Angle 40.8
Crown % 12.5

Girdle 4% - Slightly Thick Faceted
Star % 45
Lower Girdle % 75
Culet None

Thank you!