Help between two ideal stones

[nebtung]

1.23 D 61.5 T 54.9 Cr /34.5 Pav/40.8 Culet 0.6 Girdle 1.7 Diameter 6.83-7.10 HSi2

D 61.5 T 55.8 Cr/34.8 Pav/ 40.8 Culet 0.5 Girdle 1.6 Diameter6.82-6.86 1.20 G SI2

Spread is 1.4 for the G and 1.3 for the H.

I was leaning towards the larger stone because on the cert, the small needle lines ondiagram (the bottom) are on the side and about 1''2 the amount of the smaller stone. Both stones have their inclusions on the second pic of the cert or the bottom, but how will this affect the beauty? Black spots?

With info given, and I know it''s hard to describe inclusions here, I need some opinions please. Pullling the trigger in the next day or so.

 

[belle]

idealscope images?

 

[nebtung]

no images

 

[Kaleigh]

Did you ask if they are eye clean?? Maybe they are, and maybe they aren''t....

 

[JulieN]

No to the first one. It is dramatically out of round, as Dancing Fire noted in the other thread. You will notice it.

 

[nebtung]

Yes they are actually both very eye clean (I have looked for two weeks to find the cleanest SI2''s I could and these fit the bill) With that said, I guess the out of round eliminates the 1.22 H. So now I could really use some thoughts on the G 1.19. Help please! I think it could be worth the $5200 price tag.

As much input as possible please.

 

[nebtung]

Thank-you guys for all your help. I decided on the 1.19 G and will be making a purchase today! Have not seen it in person, but hopefully my two month search for the cleanest SI2 pays off. The table is spotless. I would have leaned toward the larger stone, but someone pointed out the fact that it was out of round which, being the novice that I am, I would not have noticed. Thanks and I will let you guys know with some pics possibly.