shape
carat
color
clarity

Have you been asked, "How much did you pay for that?"

DoctorD

Rough_Rock
Joined
Mar 4, 2011
Messages
48
Have you been asked, "How much did you pay for that?" by a stranger pointing to some jewelry you are wearing? I've never found a satisfactory answer. Certainly it's "none of their business," but I don't want to say that. I've faced negativity about my jewelry, so when someone asks in a positive, friendly way, I'd like to prolong, rather than end, the conversation.

I've had a relationship with my jewelers for over 20 years. Years ago I invested in their business so, among other things, they could make the necessary trips to Antwerp, Johannesburg and New York to buy roughs. As a result, I pay a fraction of retail for their work. They tell me my bracelet would sell for $90-100K, but I paid a third of that.

I was poor as a kid, so I'm proud I can afford luxuries, and part of me would like to answer the question with the retail price. But that's not true, and seems like bragging. On the other hand, the discount price is misleading if the asker would like to find one himself; s/he won't be able to.

I've tried joking "More than I should have," or lying "it was a gift." To ask, "Why do you want to know?" seems antagonistic. Overhearing me being asked, a friend once blurted out (after a few drinks), "More than you make in a year!" I'd never say anything so rude (even if it's true).

A conversation started about jewelry, just like any topic, can lead to acquaintainship, or even friendship. Twice, it eventually led to my offering them a job. This shared interest strengthened bonds between my best friends and me over the years. We've been in "competition" to reach $100K, and then a quarter-mil, in our dress business-wear jewelry.

The reason I'm prompted to write now is as follows. At a recent industry dinner, a staff member said that after looking around, he concluded my wedding ring was worth more than the 200 men there combined. That gave me pause; I had never thought of such a comparison, it was a different twist on the "rags to riches" theme. The thought was so worthwhile and thought-provoking to me that I told him he was in for a raise. A guy nearby (someone we didn't know) probably overheard, because he asked the "how much" question, but his demeanor was negative and unpleasant. My staff suggested he leave. When he became insulting, I commanded him to zip it and get lost. He disobeyed my orders, so we walked him out a side door. Fool that he was, he threw the first punch, despite the fact that a fist comparison was like tennis balls to melons. My buds watched, but didn't participate, as I punished the guy. After several very satisfying backhands and punches, I told him I'd stop if he went back and apologized to everyone. As he did, I almost laughed at the clearly defined marks my rings had made on his face and shaved head as they swelled up.

This is the first time I resorted to violence over this, and although my sons loved the story, it certainly isn't the answer, either. It annoyed me to be without my favorite rings the next day while they were being cleaned.

BTW, there seem to be cultural differences regarding this. The askers seem always to be Latino. Your thoughts on this?

Have you been asked this question, or similar? How have you handled it? If your screen name is gender-neutral, let me know if you're male or female. Thank you in advance.
 

braga123

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Apr 24, 2013
Messages
633
Maybe it's time that you change your social circle or the places you frequent. You seem to find yourself surrounded by ignorant folk.
As for the observation on Latino's....I would venture to guess that their asking is probably more a result of their lack of education than their culture. I know many educated Latino's who know better.
 

kenny

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Apr 30, 2005
Messages
33,280
Yes.
I usually lie and say it was a gift.
 

msop04

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Dec 3, 2011
Messages
10,051
DoctorD|1375416501|3495029 said:
This is the first time I resorted to violence over this...

BTW, there seem to be cultural differences regarding this. The askers seem always to be Latino. Your thoughts on this?

Have you been asked this question, or similar? How have you handled it? If your screen name is gender-neutral, let me know if you're male or female. Thank you in advance.

Yes, I've been asked this regarding my ering. I don't think it's so much cultural as it is simply "not knowing any better"/lack of social etiquette. I don't think it has anything to do with being Latino or any other culture. Those people are present in every culture. Some ask because they really just want to know, not because they are being negative.

I usually just say it was a gift or that I don't know... :|
 

GreenBling

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Oct 8, 2011
Messages
662
I was once asked by a cashier lady in a foreign country if my diamond was real. She asked it very nicely so I did answer her only to regret it...what if someone with bad intention overheard us? I'd be putting myself in danger! I'd tell strangers my jewelry is fake if I'm ever asked again.
 

HollyDolly

Rough_Rock
Joined
Nov 14, 2012
Messages
45
Re: Have you been asked, "How much did you pay for that?"

I have been asked this quite recently and answered 'we bought it in America where diamonds are cheaper so I made sure I got the most I could for the money!' it wasnt pursued further than that. I get a fair few negative types of comments because I have a 1.41 which is probably twice as big as the norm for my friends. However I also spent HOURS researching diamonds and his to get the best bang for my buck so I take the comments as compliments even if they don't come from a good place : lol:
 

Gypsy

Super_Ideal_Rock
Joined
Aug 8, 2005
Messages
40,225
Yes.
People ask. I answer honestly.
 

GoSounders

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Jul 8, 2013
Messages
181
I can see the question being a lot more acceptable when a man is wearing a $90k diamond bracelet. That's some serious bling, and pretty much welcomes attention and inquiry.

I do find it odd that you feel justified in beating on someone much smaller than you because they commented negatively about your jewelry. Really just TMI about that whole situation.
 

madelise

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
5,384
Yes, I do get asked. ALL. THE. TIME.

"I don't know, SO bought it."
"That's not nice to ask."
"How much do you get paid annually?" (hinting that financial Qs are rude)

I like bling. I wish it didn't cost as much as it does. I don't like telling people that I have thousands of dollars worth of stuff on me. I don't want to get mugged.
 

madelise

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
5,384
GoSounders|1375428579|3495111 said:
I do find it odd that you feel justified in beating on someone much smaller than you because they commented negatively about your jewelry. Really just TMI about that whole situation.


Yes. I also find it odd that you use language like "command him" and he "disobeyed your orders".. that you "punished" him… and that you "almost laughed at the clearly defined marks your rings had made on his face and shaved head as they swelled up." And that you have a competition with someone to get a wardrobe of jewelry worth a quarter million.


You sound like a pompous jerk. This whole thread reeks that you're really just trying to show off how much money you spend and how macho you are. I either sniff a troll making up stories, which I HOPE is the case, or just a big jerk.
 

LaraOnline

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Feb 24, 2008
Messages
3,365
LOL.
In Australia it wouldn't do to be seen as flashy, so here we'd be inclined to talk it down, rather than up.
Or maybe that's just my social circle (middle class professional in suburbs). We 're just not rich and flashy enough to really get into the conspicuous consumption thing (although we may like dressing well, including nice jewellery).

Sydney and Melbourne girls may think and act differently.

So if a good friend asked, in a friendly way, I would either halve the price (bit like talking to a husband lol) and only come close to telling her the truth if I got a stand-out screaming bargain.

I can't help but notice that modern rich people and celebrities are very careful not to flash too much bling around these days. They carefully assume a 'person next door' look, although their clothes might be beautiful and expensive. Boring, but it shows the power of at least appearing democratic / socially aware heheh. Australia is very 'socially aware'...exhaustively so, it seems, these days...

I feel like the kid in the back of the car: 'Are we at socialism yet?' But I digress.

ETA: The only person who has asked me directly about my lovely 3.14 RHR has been a fellow school mum that actively dislikes me.
All my friends, friendly aquaintances and relatives have studiously ignored it.
 

missy

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jun 8, 2008
Messages
54,136
Gypsy|1375427126|3495099 said:
Yes.
People ask. I answer honestly.

If I am close with the person I answer honestly. If it is none of their business (acquaintance, colleague, someone I am not close with etc) I just answer vaguely (I might just answer it cost a lot or not too much depending on the item). Or I come out and tell them I am not comfortable discussing the cost with them.

I am a pretty straightforward person and if something makes me uncomfortable for whatever reason I will share that emotion with the person unless it feels inappropriate to do so. But I will add that nothing makes me more excited than to share a good jewelry deal with those I like so when I get something for a good deal I will share away so my friends can take advantage of the offer as well if possible.
 

Slickk

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jan 3, 2013
Messages
5,009
That's rude to ask someone what they paid for anything. My husband and I always just say:

"I paid what it cost!" Done. Lol. :Up_to_something:
 

SophiesDream

Rough_Rock
Joined
Mar 24, 2013
Messages
69
madelise|1375429792|3495117 said:
GoSounders|1375428579|3495111 said:
I do find it odd that you feel justified in beating on someone much smaller than you because they commented negatively about your jewelry. Really just TMI about that whole situation.


Yes. I also find it odd that you use language like "command him" and he "disobeyed your orders".. that you "punished" him… and that you "almost laughed at the clearly defined marks your rings had made on his face and shaved head as they swelled up." And that you have a competition with someone to get a wardrobe of jewelry worth a quarter million.


You sound like a pompous jerk. This whole thread reeks that you're really just trying to show off how much money you spend and how macho you are. I either sniff a troll making up stories, which I HOPE is the case, or just a big jerk.

I read this earlier and was not sure of I should say anything or not as I'm only new, but really this whole post is like I have this I have that I beat him... Dude you aren't a king and to me it sounds like your major overcompensating for something. That's the beauty of the Internet, you can be anything you want to be! I just found this whole post ridiculous. Then again maybe I'm just cheap :razz:
 

chrono

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Apr 22, 2004
Messages
38,364
Dr.D,
It appears that you need to chill as well; your described actions were unnecessary and reeked of perceived superiority. Perhaps it is your social circle as I've never been asked by any of my friends, family nor acquaintance the price I paid for any of my jewellery.
 

yssie

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
27,268
madelise|1375429792|3495117 said:
GoSounders|1375428579|3495111 said:
I do find it odd that you feel justified in beating on someone much smaller than you because they commented negatively about your jewelry. Really just TMI about that whole situation.


Yes. I also find it odd that you use language like "command him" and he "disobeyed your orders".. that you "punished" him… and that you "almost laughed at the clearly defined marks your rings had made on his face and shaved head as they swelled up." And that you have a competition with someone to get a wardrobe of jewelry worth a quarter million.


You sound like a pompous jerk. This whole thread reeks that you're really just trying to show off how much money you spend and how macho you are. I either sniff a troll making up stories, which I HOPE is the case, or just a big jerk.
My thoughts in a nutshell.
OP, if you're real and if this scenario was real, I think both your attitude and yoursocial circle are in desperate need of some adjustment.
 

diamondseeker2006

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jan 11, 2006
Messages
58,547
No, I have never been asked. It is a rude question, and I would never answer with the actual amount. I might say it was a gift or I had to save awhile to get it. If a friend asked me because they are wanting something similar, then I'd probably tell them I can show them some current prices online and take them to the websites.

I also do not approve of hitting someone smaller even if they threw the first punch. Surely your staff could have either locked him out or you could have threatened to call the police.
 

Niel

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jul 23, 2012
Messages
20,047
I bought a cheap ring on eBay last week. I've been so excited to tell everyone, that a few people have guessed. My sister said "was that as expensive as it looks"


But you come off as a mobster in this story.
 

teobdl

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
May 8, 2013
Messages
986
Either ignore the question or beat the guy half to death. Both are equally acceptable responses. :shock:
 

msop04

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Dec 3, 2011
Messages
10,051
Sandeek|1375442465|3495163 said:
That's rude to ask someone what they paid for anything. My husband and I always just say:

"I paid what it cost!" Done. Lol. :Up_to_something:

I'm totally saying this next time! :lol:
 

msop04

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Dec 3, 2011
Messages
10,051
Yssie|1375446833|3495193 said:
madelise|1375429792|3495117 said:
GoSounders|1375428579|3495111 said:
I do find it odd that you feel justified in beating on someone much smaller than you because they commented negatively about your jewelry. Really just TMI about that whole situation.


Yes. I also find it odd that you use language like "command him" and he "disobeyed your orders".. that you "punished" him… and that you "almost laughed at the clearly defined marks your rings had made on his face and shaved head as they swelled up." And that you have a competition with someone to get a wardrobe of jewelry worth a quarter million.


You sound like a pompous jerk. This whole thread reeks that you're really just trying to show off how much money you spend and how macho you are. I either sniff a troll making up stories, which I HOPE is the case, or just a big jerk.
My thoughts in a nutshell.
OP, if you're real and if this scenario was real, I think both your attitude and yoursocial circle are in desperate need of some adjustment.

Yeeaaahhhhh.... This was how I felt as well. :???: :roll:
 

Slickk

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jan 3, 2013
Messages
5,009
msop04|1375455349|3495266 said:
Sandeek|1375442465|3495163 said:
That's rude to ask someone what they paid for anything. My husband and I always just say:

"I paid what it cost!" Done. Lol. :Up_to_something:

I'm totally saying this next time! :lol:

It works every time. Shuts them right down. Lol
 

Christina...

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Messages
5,028
Sandeek|1375456090|3495276 said:
msop04|1375455349|3495266 said:
Sandeek|1375442465|3495163 said:
That's rude to ask someone what they paid for anything. My husband and I always just say:

"I paid what it cost!" Done. Lol. :Up_to_something:

I'm totally saying this next time! :lol:

It works every time. Shuts them right down. Lol

I've chosen not to respond to the OP but I did want to respond to Sandeek....you're brilliant! I love this and will use it in the future! :appl:
 

Slickk

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jan 3, 2013
Messages
5,009
Christina...|1375457390|3495285 said:
Sandeek|1375456090|3495276 said:
msop04|1375455349|3495266 said:
Sandeek|1375442465|3495163 said:
That's rude to ask someone what they paid for anything. My husband and I always just say:

"I paid what it cost!" Done. Lol. :Up_to_something:

I'm totally saying this next time! :lol:

It works every time. Shuts them right down. Lol

I've chosen not to respond to the OP but I did want to respond to Sandeek....you're brilliant! I love this and will use it in the future! :appl:


Thank you, Christina. You're very kind. I am happy to share my response to the inappropriate question.
 

msop04

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Dec 3, 2011
Messages
10,051
blackprophet|1375458552|3495295 said:

Thanks for posting this, blackprophet. It says a lot... doesn't justify anything, but is certainly explanatory. :| (sorry, I'm still trying to pick up my jaw from the floor) :shock: ::)
 
D

Deactivated member 42515

Guest
Re: Have you been asked, "How much did you pay for that?"

Ughhh, I cannot take this anymore. You come off as a pompous arrogant fool. With a little bit of douche bag on the side.

Men that wear jewelry is an awesome thing. I appreciate a man with fine jewelry. Dancing Fire, Kenny, Gregchang. None of these men make it a point to look down on people just because they have it better than others. The way you talk makes me wanna punch YOU. You always have to add in a little arrogant flair. And beating someone up and making them apologize in front of the whole party is just uncalled for. And smirking about how the marks of your rings were still on his face? I actually laughed when I read that. It just seemed so fake and stupid.

As for the Latino remark... I don't even know what to say... Racism is not accepted here. Nor is it a accepted anywhere. Do you know that our president is African American! Oh my god!!!! Don't go beating him up too.
 

Niel

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jul 23, 2012
Messages
20,047
Re: Have you been asked,

YT|1375461332|3495330 said:
Ughhh, I cannot take this anymore. You come off as a pompous arrogant fool. With a little bit of douche bag on the side.

Men that wear jewelry is an awesome thing. I appreciate a man with fine jewelry. Dancing Fire, Kenny, Gregchang. None of these men make it a point to look down on people just because they have it better than others. The way you talk makes me wanna punch YOU. You always have to add in a little arrogant flair. And beating someone up and making them apologize in front of the whole party is just uncalled for. And smirking about how the marks of your rings were still on his face? I actually laughed when I read that. It just seemed so fake and stupid.

As for the Latino remark... I don't even know what to say... Racism is not accepted here. Nor is it a accepted anywhere. Do you know that our president is African American! Oh my god!!!! Don't go beating him up too.

I might add that we all have diamonds. So the fact you paid a lot for them isn't as impressive as I think you think it is here.

So if your telling this story to sound impressive, I might try a different forum.
 

peonyinlove

Rough_Rock
Joined
Jul 24, 2013
Messages
95
msop04|1375455572|3495270 said:
Yssie|1375446833|3495193 said:
madelise|1375429792|3495117 said:
GoSounders|1375428579|3495111 said:
I do find it odd that you feel justified in beating on someone much smaller than you because they commented negatively about your jewelry. Really just TMI about that whole situation.


Yes. I also find it odd that you use language like "command him" and he "disobeyed your orders".. that you "punished" him… and that you "almost laughed at the clearly defined marks your rings had made on his face and shaved head as they swelled up." And that you have a competition with someone to get a wardrobe of jewelry worth a quarter million.


You sound like a pompous jerk. This whole thread reeks that you're really just trying to show off how much money you spend and how macho you are. I either sniff a troll making up stories, which I HOPE is the case, or just a big jerk.
My thoughts in a nutshell.
OP, if you're real and if this scenario was real, I think both your attitude and yoursocial circle are in desperate need of some adjustment.

Yeeaaahhhhh.... This was how I felt as well. :???: :roll:

me too - if the OP actually wanted an answer to the 'do you tell what it cost?' question, about nine tenths of the post didn't need to be said. I found the violence particularly disgusting, and unfortunately it seems that even with all the expensive purchases, common sense and class weren't found along the way.
 

peonyinlove

Rough_Rock
Joined
Jul 24, 2013
Messages
95
Additionally, why is replying 'I'm an investor in this particular jeweller's business, I'm lucky to be able to buy pieces like this at or near cost' not feasible? seems like a far more gracious and simpler solution than you've apparently thought to employ so far...
 
Be a part of the community Get 3 HCA Results
Top