shape
carat
color
clarity

Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the cut

whitewave

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Feb 29, 2012
Messages
12,369
LOL... I'm 42 and this is my upgrade ring. My first ring we bought when we were 23, young and dumb (no offense.. internet was new and there was no real great way for independent education... I had Tiffany send me a booklet).

That ring is a .75 round, color H, FLAWED not only can you see chunks of carbon, but there is also a bubble in it that you can see if you have the ring in your hand and are looking at it closely.

We have been married 16.5 years now and I figured unless I bought the exact ring I wanted, I was never going to get it.

I bought an Asscher
GIA
very good cut
1.52 carat
G color
VS1 (nothing on the middle face of the diamond)
Very good symmetry
Excellent polish
69.7% depth
62% table
6.35mm x 6.15mm x 4.29 mm

I had it set in a 4 prong platinum setting.

I went back and forth about the settings because I do like Halo settings. BUT the reason I have always loved Asschers is because of the stone itself. I'm not looking for a giant piece of bling. I am looking for a beautiful and intricate stone.

So I have been reading about how a 1.5 Asscher only faces up like a 1 round. Here are my thoughts on that.... I totally understand that point.

But to me, a 1.52 Asscher looks like a 1.52 Asscher. The general public may believe it is a 1 carat, but Asscher lovers will know it is an excellent stone.

NOW... I haven't seen my ring in person yet. lol. It comes tomorrow! With Blue Nile, they have the 30 day return policy and this stone does qualify for their diamond upgrade policy. However, that policy states that the new diamond has to be 100% greater than the original stone. So for a 12K diamond, the new one would have to be 24K or more.

I honestly think that is dumb. I guess BN doesn't want a bunch of people upgrading every few years. I don't understand why they would turn down someone trading a 12k diamond for an 18k diamond, for example.... that is a 6K profit for them (minus housekeeping, etc).

So the way I look at it... I have 30 days to BE SURE this is what I want. I know Asschers have a learning curve and it is a cut you really shouldn't buy online. But I live in a small down and no jewelry stores carry Asschers anyway.

I am so excited to share this with others! Dh isn't thrilled I did this, but we can most definitely afford it (not a question) and he is nearly over it 2 days later. lol.

See you guys tomorrow with a photo!

WW
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

BTW, does anyone have any comments on the diamond based on what I wrote out? I know people will have comments when I post a photo, but does anyone who knows Asschers have any comments?

I am hoping I did well. I tried to go back to BN and find more specs for it, but I can't seem to do that now.

PINS AND NEEDLES!!!!! I can't wait to get this ring!
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

The numbers so far look promising but that doesn't tell you much at all.
When you get it view it in as many lighting conditions as possible and post some pics.
Strait up, slight tilted, side view will be a good start.
 
I hope it works out!!
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

I will definitely post pictures in all directions. Once the 30 day return period is up, I will have to spend another 12K to get a new diamond, lol. So I want to make sure this stone draws me in-- Like I mentioned, I'm not going for giant flashy bling. I'm going for beautiful Asscher cut.
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

Asschers vary SO much in appearance and cut quality. You can see this on another current thread. You'll be extremely lucky if this turns out to be a great stone, and I hope you will be! If it doesn't work out, I strongly suggest using a vendor who will provide you with pictures and ASET images. Good luck, though!
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

Yeah, it really seems to be the one stone you shouldn't buy without comparing it to other stones. I'm SOL living here and trying to find an asscher.

The ring is supposed to come with the GCal report also, so I will post that as well.
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

OMG. Lol. i am so excited that I can't sleep! the ring has made it from Seattle to Memphis! Surely will be here tomorrow!

BN doesn't show pics, but you can see a few pics of asschers other people bought: http://www.bluenile.com/engagement-rings/recently-purchased-engagement-rings

It isn't a great resource-- only keeps me going until I see my ring!

WW
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

I hope it turns out to be a nice one!
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

Me too! Naturally today is the day fed ex doesn't get here till late afternoon! KILLING ME...
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

It is here!!!!!

My initial reaction is that it looks small. (which I knew going in). It appears to be a stunning diamond, and I am working on photos now. I am sort of wishing I had gone up to a 1.75 or so, but this one cost me about 12,300K so I maxed out on my budget.

I won't trade up since the diamond itself appears to be gorgeous. O.K. Going to take some photos!!!
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

ring.jpg


Going to get my big daddy camera out. Want honest opinions on the quality of the diamond (the technical issues) once I get photos posted. thanks!!!
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

Karl K is an expert on asschers and there are a couple of others here who can tell you as well.
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

a close up

ring1.jpg
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

I guess that is a "dead step" on the left?
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

ring4.jpg


ring3.jpg

ring2.jpg
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

I hope Karl or Gypsy will see this and give you some input. Here is the stone someone else just chose and maybe you can compare the one you are looking at to this one and see how you think they compare:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MxE18W9_usk
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

I am going to bump this up for you so hopefully one of the asscher people will see it!
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

I see it, but it would help if you took the ORIGINAL pic and at 100% size you cropped it so it was just the stone in multiple images.
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

Well ... you made me go clean my similarly sized asscher ... so THANKS for that! Yikes - it needed quite a scrub! My first impression from the photos were "the windmills look a little thin -- kinda baguette/icy - rather than full on stop-sign Asscher" But my own Asscher has narrowish windmills - so I was trying to compare what mine looks like in real life, on my hand vs. what yours looks like in magnified photos.

I think the conclusion I came to (other than "OOOHH SHINY" to my own refreshed sparkly) -- is that Asschers are an individual taste thing. There is no "good" Asscher & no "bad" Asscher. It's all about what individual people like & respond to about the cut. Some of us *prefer* the ice-cube kind of clean, prismic sitch .... and others only want the perfectly stop sign Royal Asscher - narrow step busy, kaliedescopeic kinda thing.

What do YOU think? Does it take your breath away? Is it what you think of when you think "Asscher"?

(Mine is exactly what I want & what I think of when I think "Asscher" ... which is probably why I'm still over the moon for it six+ years later, DESPITE it not being *everyone*'s *ideal* Asscher. If I felt I "settled", maybe I'd still be trying to right that wrong. So I encourage you to be sure this is *it* for you NOW!)
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

I'm in love with this diamond! I keep staring at it and yes, I did notice last night that it is more of the "square emerald", which it says on the GIA report, rather than an octagon royal asscher/asscher cut.

It is more brilliant than I thought it would be-- it is quite sparkly. The windmills are a bit thin, but with the clarity of it, the steps, the sparkle... It is a keeper.

I've always loved the traditional emerald cut also, which is why I think I like this one so much...

Thanks, everyone!
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

Some quick iphone photos, then I have bunches of errands to run...

ringfinger-1.jpg



ringbroccoli.jpg


ringbroccoil2.jpg
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

I cant seem to get the photos between macro and normal. Either too big or too small! Will try again later...
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

Gypsy|1330662030|3138943 said:
I see it, but it would help if you took the ORIGINAL pic and at 100% size you cropped it so it was just the stone in multiple images.


I don't understand this. These are macro shots with no cropping. I think you want me to post some "normal" shots of the ring? Is that right?
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

She wanted the close-ups cropped so just the stone would show and not reduced in size to better see the facets.
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

o.k. Thank you! This diamond has a L to W ratio of 1.3

The only other diamond at BN is a 1.8 carat HVS1, very good cut, depth 67.7, table 60.0 with excellent polish, very good symmetry, faint fluorescence, slightly thick girdle... for about 1,200 more. oh, it also has a L to W ratio of 1.00

Again, with BN... can't see the actual diamond, though I could try and call and INSIST they take a photo of that one. Also, my DH would probably have a high blood pressure attack if I spent a dime more....

This particular diamond is beautiful to the untrained eye. Still, I would like to know the flaws of what I purchased. So I appreciate the time it takes to tell me. THANK YOU.

ring1-1.jpg



ring4-1.jpg


These are hosted on another site. I couldn't figure out how to upload them on this site... I found where to do it... my computer wouldn't upload them...
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

Whitewave, this looks like a great stone but now i can even sort of see what Karl talks about in the dead step analysis in one my posts. It looks like there's a dead step but other than that this looks to be a beauty. I spent about 2 months looking for mine and it arrives tomorrow (I have the stone in the WF youtube link someone posted).

I didn't like BN for the lack of pictures but must stress and agree with others here that you have to inspect the heck out of Asschers in person!

Hope this helps a bit...
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

It looks like your asscher is the royal asscher cut, which of course is gorgeous! Please post photos when you get it!

I don't know if that is a dead step or just the reflection in the way I took the photos because it seems when I turn the ring around, the same area reflects the same way, even though that area in the photo is now on the other side.

LOL.
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

I made a youtube video. lol. it isn't great and kind of shaky since I was making a video on the iphone while holding a magnifying glass.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ozwGpizAPXc

Clearly I am obsessed with this ring. lol.
 
Re: Getting my 1.52 Asscher tomorrow! And my thoughts on the

It has a dead facet and some darkness under the table, but honestly so do a lot of asschers. But I think it's a pretty stone and definitely not a dog. Very impressive for a stone bought sight unseen especially. It would help to know the crown height, and I can't tell much from the video as it's not being moved side to side and up and down.

Great job on the cropping. :wink2:
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top