Fsi1 hearts&a's .9 Holloway or Dsi2 cln AGS0 .2 Holloway

[clay]

I am trying to decide between 2 stones for a Tiffany engagement setting:
An Fsi1 hearts & arrow's AGS0 with a .9 Holloway score or
a clean Dsi2 AGS0 (non hearts and arrows)with a .3! Holloway score.
The D is a couple hundred bucks less than the F. I know that both are going to look great - which one is better?
Thanks for your help!
clay

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

Assumption - you have not seen the stones.
The small difference in HCA score may be less important than an SI2 if you can see the inclusion. i would consider the F SI1, or ask for both to be shipped to an appraiser.

 

[clay]

Assumption - you have not seen the stones.
Yeah - internet purchase.
Excluding the inclusion issue for a moment - which one do you believe would appear more brilliant? The H&A @ .9 or the ideal @ .2?
Thanks,
Clay