Diamond reserved...one last question

[misterov]

Well, maybe two.

First, I would very much appreciate any comments or concerns regarding this diamond: http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/7746/

Second, is the extra money for the diamond above worth it in comparison to this diamond: http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/7701/

Thank you again, this community rocks!

 

[ecf8503]

I'd prefer the color and shape of the I, but ultimately it is up to you if you are color sensitive or not and what shape you prefer. I have had 2 AVC, one rectangular and one more square, and I prefer the square shape myself. Both are beautiful, but I think the IS and ASET are nicer on the I.

 

[missydebby]

I think they are both winners. Without seeing them in person, I can't say how much of a color diff there is. I do own J AVC twins (studs) and in mine, the color just looks nice and soft vs looking toned.

For my ering, I have a more rectangular cushion that is set North/South, which I really like cause it lengthens my fingers, which are thinnish, but knobby and short. If your intended has similar fingers, that could be an option.

Here is a picture of my rectangular non-AVC on my type finger (Stats for ref: 1.01 E on size 5):


Now, having said all of that, if I were just looking at the two aesthetically, I prefer then slightly whiter and slightly squarer first one. The shape is just beautiful. Hope that helps you in relative merits!

 

[misterov]

Thanks for the suggestions everyone.

That is an interesting idea with a more rectangular diamond and I really like your ring Miss Debby. Its beautiful.

I am torn right now. I do like the shape of the I and would love for the stone to be a bright as possible. But, the J's shape is distinctly different, and may allow for more money on the setting.

Miss Debby, can I ask what kind of setting you have. I am interested in the Tacori 26020, but its probably out of my price range. I like the classic style with pave.

 

[iota15]

If it helps, I believe MissyDebby has a Leon (custom made - artofplatinum.com). The 2620 is beautiful. Personally, I prefer longer stones but I'm sure both are beautiful. The light performance of the I color is probably a bit better, but in the end, I'd consider what type of setting and the cost of the setting I want, and go from there. Some settings lend themselves better to longer stones but it's easier to find a setting for a squarer/round stone though.

Have you priced out the 2620?

 

[misterov]

If it helps, I believe MissyDebby has a Leon (custom made - artofplatinum.com). The 2620 is beautiful. Personally, I prefer longer stones but I'm sure both are beautiful. The light performance of the I color is probably a bit better, but in the end, I'd consider what type of setting and the cost of the setting I want, and go from there. Some settings lend themselves better to longer stones but it's easier to find a setting for a squarer/round stone though.

Have you priced out the 2620?

Thanks for the help. I think I remember reading about her setting now.

I agree that the longer stones are attractive. I don't think I have a strong feeling on the shape of one diamond over the other, especially without knowing the setting. I asked GOG to provide some settings similar to the 2620 (which was approx. $2,600). Maybe once I have narrowed down those choices I will have a better idea of the combination of stone/setting I prefer.

If I went with the J, I probably could swing the 2620 as it would be approx $600 over my $6,000 budget. But, I think I might want to spend that extra money on the diamond, rather than the setting.

AHH! This is fun, but confusing!