Confused about which diamond to select

[Arthur]

I am debating between these two diamons. Any comments will be appreciated.

Stone 1:

Size: 1.25
Clarity: VS-2
Color: F
Flourecense: N
Polish: EX
Symmetry: EX
Total Depth: 61.8
Table Diameter 57
Crown Angle 34.7
Crown Height 15.1
Pavillion Angle 40.9
Pavillion Depth 42.9
Girdle M
Culet: N
Measurements: 6.91 - 6.94 x 4.28
Price: $8,680.00
GIA Certified


Stone 2:
H&A:
Size: 1.11
Clarity: VVS-2
Color: E
Flourecense: N
Polish: EX
Symmetry: EX
Total Depth: 60.5
Table Diameter: 57
Crown Angle: 33.8
Crown Height 14.7
Pavillion Angle: 40.9
Pavillion Depth: 43.3
Girdle: N-M-F
Culet: N
Measurements: 6.72 - 6.76 x 4.08
$9,450.00
GIA Certified

I am been trying to determine which stone offers better value.

 

[pricescope]

From price/carat point of view they are identical in respect to Rapaport report.

I'd go with the bigger and cheaper one What's the point to pay for VVS2 clarity?

 

[scaasi]

I would too go with the bigger one, although I know you can do better as far as a price is concerned!!!

Glad to help.

Isaac
www.dSCAASI.com