Comparing Ovals

[svoss]

Greetings,
My husband and I will be upgrading(trade in) my .81 SI1, J Oval for a larger Oval. I have had good experiences with this jeweler but I am wanting additional education that I hope your feedback will provide.
The two we are narrower our choice down to are

1) 1.21 Oval
GIA cert.
SI1, I 7.89*5.91*3.84
Med to thick girdle Polish- V. Good and Sym.- Good
No flour.
$5,249

2) 1.37 Oval
No certification
J, SI1 7.87*6.05*3.98
Med to thick girdle Polish V.Good and Sym,- Good
No flour.
$5.280


Thanks in advance for your time,

 

[svoss]

Sorry, I meant to say that we have narrowed down our search to these two stones.


Thanks again for your feedback,

 

[RockDoc]

You need a lot more information about the stone proportions, and even then it is IMPOSSIBLE to render you an accurate opinion without SEEING THE DIAMONDS.


Find an expert and get all the info.... so you will get expert opinion. That you should be able to rely on.

Advice for Unseen diamonds means little..... but then it YOUR money and choice of course.

Rockdoc