- Jun 25, 2010
since we know everyone prefers cut- I thought we would compare clarity, carat, color
Dreamer_D|1315436901|3012080 said:I alway think the biggest one looks the best so carat is pretty clearly a winner for me
I agree with this. Also, I don't even care if its eye clean as long as the inclusions aren't distracting or ugly. I've seen some very nice I1s and even I2s. It really makes a difference what sort of inclusions they are, and where. Also, what sort of piece! For earrings, I would not want to "waste" a VS stone. For that matter, I am not nearly so cut-obsessed as most of PS. You don't need to have an ideally cut diamond for it to sparkle like mad. It's still a diamond.centralsquare|1315458014|3012405 said:As long as it's eye clean, I don't care about clarity. I don't care about color above an H (ering) and J (other pieces). Then it's all about carat!!