can I go wrong with either of these?

[sbraith]

So barring the unforeseen, I will buy on of these stones this week. They are both AGS 0 F VS2''s. Same price, no upgrade policy on either.

I like the numbers of this stone better:

Carat .828
HCA 1.2
Table 55%
Depth 61.8%
Crown 33.9
Pav 40.9
Girdle 1.5-3.9
Hearts/Arrows ???

Better service from the vendor on this one
(they''ll call in and review stones with you in person. I''ll be able to see it before I buy it)

Carat .816
HCA 1.4
Table 55%
Depth 62.5%
Crown 34.6
Pav 40.8
Girdle 1.7-4.8
Hearts/Arrows yes

Am I missing something, or are both solid choices.

Thanks

 

[stone-cold11]

Both are solid choices.

 

[About2ask]

how much?

 

[neatfreak]

Both are solid choices but I''d personally prefer to work with a vendor with an upgrade policy, you never know what you might need later!

 

[sbraith]

$3800

 

[stone-cold11]

Weird. I found both stones on BN but no longer available, so probably call up by your vendors. About the price you listed.

I do not see how one vendor could have known the stone is a H&A before hand.

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 12/2/2008 7:39:32 PM
Author:sbraith
So barring the unforeseen, I will buy on of these stones this week. They are both AGS 0 F VS2''s. Same price, no upgrade policy on either.

I like the numbers of this stone better:

Carat .828
HCA 1.2
Table 55%
Depth 61.8%
Crown 33.9
Pav 40.9
Girdle 1.5-3.9
Hearts/Arrows ???

Better service from the vendor on this one
(they''ll call in and review stones with you in person. I''ll be able to see it before I buy it)

Carat .816
HCA 1.4
Table 55%
Depth 62.5%
Crown 34.6
Pav 40.8
Girdle 1.7-4.8
Hearts/Arrows yes

Am I missing something, or are both solid choices.

Thanks

Either could be great, find out how the vendors are qualifying either diamond to be hearts and arrows though.