I just told her that I have a 2mm band. We haven't gotten to whether I should send it to her. Here is a picture of my wedding rings.Got it! Makes total sense!
is DK making the band seen on the CAD as well, or is that for visual purposes only/ for a band you already have? If it’s for a band you already have, did you send it to DK or is it a generic representation of a band?
I think with your set, flush makes sense. I wouldn't mess with that beautiful basket, unless it was, as @Rfisher said, to make them a tad more swoopy. If you decide this is what you want, just make sure you tell Amy that you want them to attach low and to have a clear, discernible swoop/curve. She'll get it - I know for a fact she's done that before.
Curved. Not straight. Swooped.
these are only my opinions - there’s no right or wrong.
this below shows what I would ask Amy to adjust on your CAD so the side profile of the shank is more tapered instead of uniform.
but much of this looking ‘right’ might also depend on the look of it next to your existing WB, and the profile of that?
and this below shows what I would ask Amy to adjust on your CAD so the shoulder profile had more of a swoop to it.
I think I would also ask to see what the difference would be in the existing taper on the cathedral/shoulder area being adjusted to the 2.2 to 1.7 measurements as stated earlier.
I like your basket as is, wouldn’t change it.
oh how I envy your finger size!
Just to be clear, the 2.2 to 1.7 width of the band is on the finished product, where I am looking to end up...yes?
This is what I got back from Amy I am wondering if I am over my head I saw this ring on their fb. Wondering if this is better. This ring is going to be the death of me
It does look like Amy did exactly what you asked - it’s just not translating well (IMO) in the outcome. That’s ok - it happens.
If you keep with this design and don’t think you want to change designs-
Ask her to return the taper at the cathedral to what it originally was -but keep the bottom of the shank measurement the 2.2.
Did you give up on any taper in the shank? I don’t see any, still.
thats fine, just making sure it’s something you didn’t want anymore.
this original taper at your cathedral area of the shank is what I was referring to, vs seeing apparently no taper in the new CAD.
no right or wrong - just what you prefer.
nothing to do with addition of the beading.
This area of taper was already removed on your November 16 posted CAD.
and you are welcome