blue nile, BE or DK for pave band

[hollyns]

Is there much difference in pave quality between BN and BE? Does anyone have the "Vanessa" band from BE? I'm now considering the following three options for a band (after my fiancé and mom did not like the CVB sophie for a wedding band ):

french pave from blue nile https://www.bluenile.com/french-pave-diamond-ring-platinum_44713?elem=img&track=product&vtype=sample

"vanessa" from BE in a half eternity https://www.brilliantlyengaged.com/vanessa-chic-micro-pave-diamond-wedding-band-pid-21-39.html

or something similar to this absolutely beautiful DK band that CRYSTAL24K has [URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/single-cut-wedding-band-by-david-klass-and-family-shots.225323/']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/single-cut-wedding-band-by-david-klass-and-family-shots.225323/[/URL]

 

[rubybeth]

Uh, I would say get the CvB Sophia, if that's what you want. Who cares what your mom and fiance think you wedding band should look like? They should want you to be happy.

This is the band, right? I have a vintage band that's engrave similar to this one, and it's awesome. https://www.etsy.com/listing/236019607/the-cvb-id-sophia-french-cut-diamond-and?ref=shop_home_active_37

 

[hollyns]

I'm definitely going to get something from her in the future as a RHR I don't mind sticking with something a bit more traditional for a wedding band since I'm going to be wearing it for the next 50+ years

 

[rubybeth]

But the Sophia is based on vintage engraved bands, which are totally classic.

 

[Austina]

I agree that it's your wedding band, so what does it matter what other people think?

I always wanted a full eternity band, but the reality is, you don't see the underside so it's a bit of a waste, and I managed to damage the underside carrying shopping and the like

 

[rubybeth]

I'm not familiar enough with Blue Nile to recommend that one. I'd suggest looking through the Whiteflash bands. I have one, with their ACA pave, and it's awesome.

Maybe this one? http://www.whiteflash.com/wedding-rings/vatche-1533-charis-pave-diamond-wedding-ring-3691.htm

 

[Vogue]

Agreed with the others--you're the one wearing the ring every day, so you should get something you're going to love looking at. Get what you like the most.

 

[hollyns]

The three options I am considering are all quite similar. I'm really just interested in people's opinions of the quality. I now regret mentioning in my original post the cvb band I was previously looking at because now rather than commenting on the three bands Ive asked about, everyone is just commenting on my personal choice to purchase a more traditional pave band. However, i felt I should offer an explanation for the change of heart because I had previously posted about the cvb sophie band.

The BN option is the cheapest, but perhaps it would be worth getting the DK or BE one instead. I've read lots of praise of DK's work on these boards, but can't find any mention of the vanessa band by BE. I know lots of people on this board are very familiar with bn, be, and dk so Im just hoping to get some opinions on these three band options so I can make an informed decision.

 

[distracts]

well realistically if you actually want a wedding band you can wear for the next 50+ years... pave is likely not the best option. A plain or engraved band, or something with bezel or channel set stones, will be far more durable.

I think most people on this board do not buy from Brilliant Earth because they are pretty overpriced for what they sell. eta Oh wait you meant Brilliantly Engaged. I keep forgetting there is a second BE floating around.

 

[hollyns]

If I eliminate the BN option, is there any benefit to going with DK or brilliantly engaged? The price points are close enough between the two that cost isnt a deciding factor. Im hoping to order one or the other this week.

 

[tweeter8177]

I have worked with brilliantly engaged and I would recommend them! I think they do a nice job with pave. You can see my bright cut pave halo ring if you search my name under show me the bling. Hope that helps!!

 

[WillyDiamond]

I have worked with brilliantly engaged and I would recommend them! I think they do a nice job with pave. You can see my bright cut pave halo ring if you search my name under show me the bling. Hope that helps!!

I have worked with them also, ask for Chris.

 

[PintoBean]

I have worked with brilliantly engaged and I would recommend them! I think they do a nice job with pave. You can see my bright cut pave halo ring if you search my name under show me the bling. Hope that helps!!

I have worked with them also, ask for Chris.

Another vote for BE! Chris is such a gentleman and always a pleasure to work with, IMHO.

 

[Kbell]

Out of the three choices I like the DK band the best. It looks like it would stand the test of time better than the other two and you'd have the opportunity to add your own touch.
The Pave looks beautiful but very delicate.

 

[WillyDiamond]

DK?

 

[Kbell]

DK?

the 3rd link she posted... David Klass.