bigbadbuff
Rough_Rock
- Joined
- Aug 25, 2004
- Messages
- 21
#1
#2
I''m having trouble deciding between these 2. Both perform about the same in Virtual Model, lightscope, and bscope tests. The biggest difference is inclusions.
The G VS1 has no visible inclusions from the top, as the cavity is only really visible from the girdle/bottom... but I don''t know about the cavity aspect, I don''t see that discussed often and it seems to be a rare inclusion. Anything wrong with the placement of this particular cavity to warrant concern? I admit I do like the idea of a cleaner stone, which this certainly is... lower in color (although it will be going in a platinum setting) but ex/ex for polish/symmetry.
The F VS2 has some small inclusions in the table but they seem small and few for a VS2 rating. I like the idea of being in the colorless range and don''t care about the inclusions here as they''d be eye clean I''m sure. vg/ex for polish/symmetry but I''ve read that matters little until you get into the higher end of clarity. Slightly better machine #s.
Not sure what to use as the deciding factors here, what would you do? Thanks in advance...
#2
I''m having trouble deciding between these 2. Both perform about the same in Virtual Model, lightscope, and bscope tests. The biggest difference is inclusions.
The G VS1 has no visible inclusions from the top, as the cavity is only really visible from the girdle/bottom... but I don''t know about the cavity aspect, I don''t see that discussed often and it seems to be a rare inclusion. Anything wrong with the placement of this particular cavity to warrant concern? I admit I do like the idea of a cleaner stone, which this certainly is... lower in color (although it will be going in a platinum setting) but ex/ex for polish/symmetry.
The F VS2 has some small inclusions in the table but they seem small and few for a VS2 rating. I like the idea of being in the colorless range and don''t care about the inclusions here as they''d be eye clean I''m sure. vg/ex for polish/symmetry but I''ve read that matters little until you get into the higher end of clarity. Slightly better machine #s.
Not sure what to use as the deciding factors here, what would you do? Thanks in advance...