Which Round For My Bezel Pendant

[Kaycee2018]

DH was kind enough to gift me a 1.29ct pear for a bezel pendant project I mentioned, but come to find out I don’t love pears and the size was larger than I wanted for an everyday wear necklace. After much deliberation, it was exchanged for a .82ct round (H VS2) and I also ordered a .85ct I VS1 in a more 60/60 style to compare it with since shallower is supposed to be better for pendants. I‘m not too worried about the I color since it is under a carat (my original e-ring diamond is 1.01ct and an I and I barely see any tint at all). Price is basically the same (less than $50 difference) and obviously these aren’t “super ideals”. I will update with pics/videos when I have both in hand, but in the meantime I am curious to know which one you seasoned PSers would pick for an everyday pendant.

.82ct H VS2 (with images) HCA is .6

0.82 carat (ct) GIA Round Loose Diamond H Color VS2 Clarity Excellent Cut

www.b2cjewels.com

.85ct I VS1 (no images available) HCA is 1.1

0.85-Carat Round Cut Diamond | Blue Nile

www.bluenile.com