Which one ??

[m2001]

Here''s some quote that I got from one of the site..


Cts Lab Shp Clr Clar Total$ Dep Tbl Dim Fluor Pol Sym
.46 GIA RD H I1 646 61.8 58 4.95x4.99x3.07 None VG G

.47 GIA RD G SI2 677 63 60 4.87x4.90x3.12 None G V

.50 GIA RD G I1 768 59.1 62 5.15x5.20x3.06 None G G

Which one should I go for..

 

[ShadowRider750]

Are you using these for a ring or pendant or other jewelry piece?

ShadowRider750

 

[m2001]

I'm planning to use it for a pendant... probably will take it to a local jeweller for setting it in a pendant.

 

[ShadowRider750]

Cts Lab Shp Clr Clar Total$ Dep Tbl Dim Fluor Pol Sym
.46 GIA RD H I1 646 61.8 58 4.95x4.99x3.07 None VG G

.47 GIA RD G SI2 677 63 60 4.87x4.90x3.12 None G V

.50 GIA RD G I1 768 59.1 62 5.15x5.20x3.06 None G G



I guess it would depend on your price range and style. I like the .46ct diamond for its proportions and color.

 

[m2001]

Thanks for your opinion.

Would appreciate any advise from other diamond experts on this topic...

 

[pqcollectibles]

Based on proportions alone #1 and #3 are your better choices. #2 is a tad deep, which you can easily see by the measurements.

Clarity is a bit of concern as both are I1. You can get an eye clean I1. I've seen one. It had to be viewed from just the right angle to see the one main inclusion that got the diamond the I1 rating. You would definintely want a refund grace period to give you a chance to see either of those, or get an independent evaluation, to decide if the one you choose will work for you.