Which one would you choose?

[qtiekiki]

I am deciding between two hoop earrings, and wanted some opinions. The thinner one seems more fun and young, and the thicker one seems more mature. I like the length of the thin one more, but I like how the pave are set in the thicker one.

#1 14kt white gold, 0.5ctw

 

[qtiekiki]

#2 14kt white gold, 0.34ctw

 

[qtiekiki]

side by side

 

[qtiekiki]

on my ear

 

[E B]

Thinner! I think they look more delicate. Classic.

 

[regalada]

I like the thin ones better.

 

[MissGotRocks]

I vote for number 2! They look more sparkly and I like the length on them. They also look more elegant to me. . .

 

[flopkins]

I see what you mean abt liking the pave setting more on the thicker one but the thin ones are the way to go!!! They look super! #2 all the way! Any significant price difference?

 

[hfollett]

The 2nd. They look more stylish and fun.

 

[qtiekiki]

I have no idea on the prices, because I was eyeing hoops and DH asked his sister (she works at a jewelry wholesaler) to show me what she has at work. I want 2ctw hoops eventually like Ann''s hoops, and was telling DH to send those back but he wants me to get something for now since I probably won''t be getting a 2 ctw anytime soon. So now I am trying to decide.

 

[Kaleigh]

I too like the thin ones!! They are fun and look great. I want one''s like Ann''s too.

 

[SeaOats]

Definitely #2

 

[cpster]

I like the thin ones, but I wish they had diamonds on the side too like the first one. Either way, you''ll have a fabulous pair of earrings!

 

[glaucomflecken]

WOW! I will go against the grain and say I like the thicker ones, only because I love thicker chunkier jewelry and love the extra bling!

lucky you!

 

[Sundial]

They are both gorgeous, but I have to go with #2!

 

[sevens one]

I like the thicker ones too.