Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go with?

[impronto]

Diamond 1:



I also have this photo of diamond 1:





Diamond 2:



Thanks in advance! And unfortunately I do not have access to idealscope images.

 

[new4diamond]

Re: Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go w

huh?...both look the same to me

 

[impronto]

Re: Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go w

huh?...both look the same to me

sorry about that, had duplicated the reports. I fixed it now.

 

[new4diamond]

Re: Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go w

Based on the reports, I like the 2nd stone

 

[impronto]

Re: Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go w

Based on the reports, I like the 2nd stone

is that based on the depth %? or the inclusion types?

 

[diamondloveaffair]

Re: Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go w

first one has a slightly thick girdle that's uniform. The image doesn't look like its a top notch performer. no comments on second stone without additional information.

 

[impronto]

Re: Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go w

first one has a slightly thick girdle that's uniform. The image doesn't look like its a top notch performer. no comments on second stone without additional information.

what from the image makes it not look as a top performer?

 

[new4diamond]

Re: Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go w

Based on the reports, I like the 2nd stone

is that based on the depth %? or the inclusion types?

The experts here on PS will ask you to post Idealscope pictures, then you can get a much better idea of how the stone will perform. If you don't have the pics ask the vender for pics, then post them.

 

[Dancing Fire]

Re: Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go w

Both are well cut stones. I like #1 b/c of the smaller table + a taller crown.

 

[04diamond<3]

Re: Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go w

They're both pretty close and since you don't have access to an ideal scope image I will just go off the reports. I also like the smaller table on the first one (although the second one is only a 56% instead of the 55% on the first stone so it won't look that much different), the only issue I have with the stone is the depth. It's a hair deep which will make the stone look a tad smaller. Not anything noticeable. Hope your purchase turns out well.

 

[impronto]

Re: Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go w

Thanks for all the replies everyone. I was told the type of inclusions makes a difference as well where diamond 2's inclusions are more preferable being a feather and needle vs diamond 1's cloud and crystal. Any comments on this?

And ya, unfortunately there is no idealscope

 

[04diamond<3]

Re: Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go w

Thanks for all the replies everyone. I was told the type of inclusions makes a difference as well where diamond 2's inclusions are more preferable being a feather and needle vs diamond 1's cloud and crystal. Any comments on this?

And ya, unfortunately there is no idealscope

Do you at least have a picture of #2? There's no way for us to tell where the inclusions are and how bad it is. Not to mention the report doesn't even have a diagram....

 

[impronto]

Re: Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go w

no unfortunately there are no photos of the 2nd. OK so from the photos info I have any f the first diamond, is that a good diamond? what's your thoughts on the first (0.92) one?

 

[04diamond<3]

Re: Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go w

It looks good!

 

[Christina...]

Re: Which one out of these two round diamonds would you go w

They are both VS1 stones so inclusions are not likely an issue. I like the 15.5% crown angle of the first stone, but truly based on the info provided, toss a coin.