Which one has more potential for fire and brilliance

[Rpb]

Okay so I have been in touch with a vendor for ideal cut lab round diamonds and he sent me these 2 options close to the super ideal ranges but not within the exact parameters.

Diamond 1 - table 60.5
Depth - 60.5
CA - 33.8
PA - 40.5
Measurements - 8.42*8.49*5.12
2.30 H VVS 1

Diamond 2 - table 56
Depth 61.8
CA - 33.3
PA - 40.9
Measurements - 8.03*8.11*4.99
2.00 I VS 1

 

[Rpb]

Diamond 1 videos2.30 H VVS 1

2.30 H VVS 1

 

[Rpb]

Diamond 2 2.00 I VS 1

Second video 2.00 I VS 1

 

[Ada Diamonds CEO]

Honestly, both appear to be fairly brown from the videos, so the color palette of the fire and brilliance will be brownish in both stones. This CVD brown tinge is not natural, and does not occur in mined diamonds. Is that something that you're okay with?

 

[OoohShiny]

The first stone is a 60/60 so will likely have more white light than coloured fire. They do tend to be shallow for their weight so will face up larger, though.

The second stone has a lower crown than we might recommend but the pavilion angle looks like it would work with it.