which is a better princess cut diamond

[shirleyo]

please help(smile)

which is the best PRINCESS DIAMOND
gia FOR BOTH RINGS
carat=1.02,COLOR=F COLOR=F
clarity= VS1
shape= princess
depth= 66.9
TABLE= 69
polish= good
symmetry= vg
culet=n
girdle= m-tk
FLUR-NONE
MEASUREMENT= 5.62X5.62X3.76


CARAT=1.03
COLOR=G
CLARITY= VVS1
SHAPE= PRINCESS
DEPTH= 68.5
TABLE= 63
POLISH= EX
SYM= EX
CULET= NONE
GIRDLE= MD-STK
FLUR= NONE
MEASUREMENT= 5.82X5.56X3.81
THANK-YOU

 

[diamondsman]

I like # 2, reaon being that it has a bigger spread in diameter,I would have liked to have a bigger table, and I would have gone for a VS quality instead of a VVS, but from the numbers you gave us, I think that #2 is the nicer stone.

 

[oldminer]

I'd prefer an F VS to a G VVS based on color clarity combinations. I'd probably prefer the cut of the G VVS, however although the information you have is insufficient to decide on which one might look the best....

You might have to consider their relative values in order to make your mind up.

 

[alexah]

That's a toughie- have you seen them in person?
Looking at princess cuts is always the best way to select one, rather than going solely by the stats.
I did notice #1 is a perfect square, desirable in princess cuts...
Good luck to you!

 

[Nicrez]

I personally would go with #1, because the table is larger, which would make it LOOK bigger for the same, and an F VS1 is a bettr combo, I agree...




I only worry that with some stones a BIG table measn a fisheye, but if you've seen the stone, and you like it I say #1! (based on an uneducated guess from not seeing the stones, or having more angle info)




Good luck!